Cover of Synthetic Nitrogen Fertilizer: Air, Fire, Bread, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book Synthetic Nitrogen Fertilizer: Air, Fire, Bread
Chapters 3, 4 and 5. Read the full book free as a PDF.

The scarcity they were solving

At the end of the nineteenth century, the world's farms ran on mined nitrogen: guano scraped off Peruvian islands and nitrate dug from the Chilean desert. Chile supplied about two thirds of the world's fertilizer nitrogen in 1900. In 1898 the chemist William Crookes, president of the British Association, warned that wheat-eating peoples were heading for starvation when the deposits ran out. Three industrial answers appeared within a decade. In Norway, Kristian Birkeland and Samuel Eyde fixed nitrogen with an electric arc, founding Norsk Hydro in 1905. In Germany and Italy, the Frank-Caro process fixed it through calcium cyanamide from 1905. Both worked, and both burned enormous amounts of energy. The third answer won.

The hunger was real. The Chincha Islands gave up some 12.5 million tonnes of guano before they were worked out, and control of the Atacama nitrate fields was worth a war: Chile fought Peru and Bolivia for them in 1879 and came out holding most of the world's fertilizer nitrogen. Crookes's warning named a date, indirectly: he reckoned the deposits and the yield ceiling together could not feed the wheat eaters of 1930.

Haber's bench

Fritz Haber was a physical chemist at the Technical College of Karlsruhe. He had measured the ammonia equilibrium and once concluded that direct synthesis was commercially hopeless; a public dispute with Walther Nernst over the numbers stung him into repeating the work, and the new data showed that high pressure made the yield worth having. With his instrument maker Robert Le Rossignol, Haber built a bench machine, found that osmium and then uranium made the reaction move, and in March 1909 showed his colleagues ammonia condensing from compressed air and hydrogen. In July 1909, watched by BASF's men, the little apparatus was producing about 250 milliliters of ammonia every two hours.

Etched profile portrait of Fritz Haber, a bald man with round spectacles and a small moustache, facing left.
Fritz Haber, in an autographed etching by Emil Orlik. The laboratory synthesis he demonstrated in 1909 still makes essentially all of the world's synthetic ammonia. Photo: Emil Orlik (1870-1932), Public domain, via DPLA and Wikimedia Commons.

Bosch's machine

Formal studio portrait of Carl Bosch in 1908, a young man with combed hair in a dark suit, seated and facing the camera.
Carl Bosch in 1908, the year BASF took up the ammonia problem. His converter design and his catalyst search turned Haber's bench drip into an industry. Photo: BASF Corporate History, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

BASF had been working on the problem since 1908. Carl Bosch, the young metallurgist-chemist in charge, looked at the drip of ammonia and said, in the words the company preserves, "I think it can work... We should risk it." The obstacles were brutal. Osmium was too rare, so Alwin Mittasch's group tested candidate catalysts by the thousand and landed on promoted iron. Hydrogen at pressure and heat ate through steel, so Bosch designed a double-walled converter, letting the corrosive gas seep through the inner wall without load on the outer one. Krupp built the vessels, converters 2.44 metres high that were the largest pressure equipment yet attempted. Construction at Oppau began in May 1911, and the plant started producing on 9 September 1913, at about 30 tonnes of ammonia a day, the date BASF itself marks as the start of industrial ammonia synthesis. A second, far larger works at Leuna followed during the war, and the pair made Germany the first country that could feed and arm itself from the air.

The rivals were not idle while BASF built. Birkeland and Eyde's arc furnaces drew 100,000 kilowatts of Norwegian waterfall by 1912, and the Frank-Caro cyanamide works spread until calcium cyanamide production peaked around 1945 at about 1.5 million tonnes a year. Both processes lived on electricity so cheap it was nearly free, and both died when Haber-Bosch economics reached their valleys. The Oppau plant, meanwhile, grew from 30 tonnes a day to 8,700 tonnes of ammonia in its first full year, converted onward into 36,000 tonnes of ammonium sulfate fertilizer.

The shadow

The war came a year later. Blockaded Germany needed nitric acid for explosives as much as for fertilizer, and Haber-Bosch plants supplied it. Haber also directed Germany's chemical warfare work and was present at the first chlorine release at Ypres in April 1915. His 1918 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, awarded for the synthesis, was protested by Allied scientists. Bosch shared the 1931 prize for high-pressure chemistry. Haber, Jewish by birth, died in exile in 1934, driven out by the state his work had armed. His first wife, Clara Immerwahr, the first woman to earn a chemistry doctorate at Breslau, had shot herself in 1915, days after Ypres.

The legacy

The process they launched now makes the reactive nitrogen that feeds roughly half of humanity. The estimate, traced by Our World in Data through Erisman and colleagues' Nature Geoscience study, is that synthetic nitrogen fertilizer supports about half of the world's population: without it, the nitrogen in the protein of every second person alive would not be there. What the machine runs on, and what it costs, is covered in why nitrogen fertilizer depends on natural gas and the environmental cost of nitrogen fertilizer.

Quick answers

Who invented the Haber-Bosch process?

Fritz Haber demonstrated ammonia synthesis from nitrogen and hydrogen on a laboratory scale in 1909. Carl Bosch and his BASF team made it industrial, with the first plant at Oppau starting production on 9 September 1913.

Did Haber and Bosch win Nobel Prizes?

Yes, separately. Haber received the 1918 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for the synthesis of ammonia. Bosch shared the 1931 prize with Friedrich Bergius for high-pressure chemical methods.

Why was the Haber-Bosch process controversial?

Because the same ammonia plants that made fertilizer supplied nitric acid for explosives in the First World War, and Haber personally directed Germany's chemical warfare program, including the first chlorine attack at Ypres in 1915.

Sources

The July 1909 rate of 250 milliliters per two hours and the Mittasch catalyst search are from the historical record as compiled in the book's Source Companion; BASF's own chronology fixes the 1913 start. Chile's two-thirds share of 1900 fertilizer nitrogen is from Wisniak and Garces, read in excerpt.

More from this book

Chemistry · From the book Synthetic Nitrogen Fertilizer: Air, Fire, Bread

How the Haber-Bosch process works

One line of chemistry feeds half the world: N2 + 3H2 becomes 2NH3.

Process · From the book Synthetic Nitrogen Fertilizer: Air, Fire, Bread

How nitrogen fertilizer is made

Almost all nitrogen fertilizer starts as two raw materials that do not look like farm inputs at all: air and natural gas.

Impact · From the book Synthetic Nitrogen Fertilizer: Air, Fire, Bread

The environmental cost of nitrogen fertilizer

Synthetic nitrogen feeds about half of humanity.