Cover of Synthetic Nitrogen Fertilizer: Air, Fire, Bread, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book Synthetic Nitrogen Fertilizer: Air, Fire, Bread
Chapters 5 and 6. Read the full book free as a PDF.

The problem: nitrogen will not react

The air is full of nitrogen, and it is nearly useless. The two atoms in a nitrogen molecule are locked together by a triple bond that is among the strongest in chemistry, which is why the atmosphere can be four fifths nitrogen and life still goes hungry for it. Splitting that bond is the toll every nitrogen-fixing process, industrial or biological, has to pay.

The reaction and its catch

The reaction itself is gentle: combine nitrogen and hydrogen into ammonia and heat comes out. That creates the trap Fritz Haber mapped in the first years of the twentieth century. Because the reaction releases heat, a cold mixture yields more ammonia at equilibrium. But cold nitrogen and hydrogen barely react at all: the rate is glacial. Heat the mixture and it reacts faster, yet the equilibrium slips back toward the raw gases. The way out is pressure. Since four molecules of gas become two molecules of ammonia, squeezing the mixture pushes the equilibrium toward the product no matter the temperature. So the process buys everything at once: high pressure for yield, high temperature for speed, and a catalyst for more speed still.

Diagram of the ammonia synthesis loop: nitrogen and hydrogen are compressed, heated and passed over the iron catalyst; the outflow is cooled, ammonia condenses out, and unreacted gas recycles.
The synthesis loop. Original IOI diagram.

Reading the equilibrium

The book puts numbers on the trap. The equilibrium constant for ammonia formation, measured in its usual units, falls steeply with temperature: in pressure-based units (atm to the power minus 2, depending on the standard state), about 0.00434 at 300 degrees Celsius against about 0.0000145 at 500 degrees. These are equilibrium constants, not the share of the mixture that turns into ammonia. Left to thermodynamics, the industry would make ammonia in a refrigerator. Left to kinetics, it would make it in a furnace where almost none survives. Pressure is the third lever, and it is the one no natural nitrogen fixer can pull. Lightning and root-nodule bacteria work at one atmosphere; a synthesis plant works at two hundred or more.

The catalyst

The working catalyst is mostly iron, made from magnetite and stiffened with promoters. It was not the first choice. Haber's 1909 laboratory machine ran on osmium, with uranium as a backup, both far too rare to build an industry on. At BASF, Carl Bosch's team, with Alwin Mittasch running the search, worked through candidate materials by the thousand and settled on a promoted iron that plants still use today. Britannica credits the iron catalyst with letting the reaction run at a lower temperature than would otherwise be practicable.

The loop

Even with everything tuned, a single pass over the catalyst converts only a fraction of the gas. The industrial answer is the loop Haber drew at the bench: cool the hot gas leaving the converter until the ammonia condenses and can be drained away, then send the unreacted nitrogen and hydrogen back through again. Removing the ammonia as soon as it forms keeps the equilibrium pulling toward product, as Britannica describes it, and the recycle turns a poor single pass into near-complete overall conversion. The price is the compressor: keeping several tonnes of gas per hour at synthesis pressure is a large share of the plant's energy bill.

Where the energy goes

Every stage pays in energy. Making the hydrogen from methane, compressing the gas to synthesis pressure, and holding the converter hot all draw on the same fuel bill, which is why the history of the process is a history of heat recovery. Modern plants reclaim the reaction's own heat to raise steam, and the big single-train designs of the 1960s, built around centrifugal compressors driven by that steam, cut the energy per tonne so deeply that C&EN marked a 600-tonne-a-day Kellogg plant in 1963 as the largest in America, a size now ordinary. The International Energy Agency puts the average energy intensity of ammonia production at about 41 gigajoules per tonne, against 28 for the best gas-based technology: the gap between the average plant and the best plant is the industry's remaining efficiency reserve.

The steel that had to hold it

The unsolved half of the problem in 1909 was not chemistry but metal. Hydrogen at synthesis pressure and temperature seeps into ordinary steel, reacts with its carbon and splits it from inside, a failure called hydrogen embrittlement. Bosch's answer was a converter within a converter: a soft inner wall that the hydrogen could attack without consequence, wrapped in a strong outer shell that carried the pressure but never touched the nascent hydrogen, because the gas was allowed to leak harmlessly through the gap. That double wall is why the process has an industrial body at all, and descendants of it stand in every ammonia plant.

Why the design endures

Essentially all synthetic ammonia made today comes from this one arrangement, scaled from Haber's bench drip to single-train plants that pour out several thousand tonnes a day. The engineering has been refined for a century, above all to cut the energy per tonne, but the logic has not changed since 1909: pressure for the equilibrium, heat for the rate, iron for the toll, and a loop for the rest. The people who made it work, and what it cost them, are in Haber and Bosch: the men who fed the world.

Quick answers

What chemical reaction does the Haber-Bosch process use?

Nitrogen and hydrogen combine into ammonia: N2 + 3H2 gives 2NH3. The reaction releases heat, so high pressure is used to keep the equilibrium on the ammonia side.

What catalyst is used in the Haber process?

An iron catalyst, made from magnetite with promoters. Haber's 1909 laboratory unit used osmium, but BASF's search program settled on promoted iron, which plants still use.

Why does the Haber-Bosch process need high pressure?

Because four molecules of gas become two of ammonia. Pressure pushes the equilibrium toward ammonia; without it, the hot mixture needed for a workable reaction rate would yield very little.

Sources

Per-pass conversion and modern plant scale are stated qualitatively for the same reason.

More from this book

Process · From the book Synthetic Nitrogen Fertilizer: Air, Fire, Bread

How nitrogen fertilizer is made

Almost all nitrogen fertilizer starts as two raw materials that do not look like farm inputs at all: air and natural gas.

History · From the book Synthetic Nitrogen Fertilizer: Air, Fire, Bread

Haber and Bosch: the men who fed the world

One man found the reaction on a laboratory bench.

Feedstock · From the book Synthetic Nitrogen Fertilizer: Air, Fire, Bread

Why nitrogen fertilizer depends on natural gas

A gas-based ammonia plant uses methane as both feedstock and fuel.