Cover of The X-ray Machine, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book The X-ray Machine
Chapters 17 to 20. Read the full book free as a PDF.

The gas tube problem

Röntgen's tubes were gas-discharge tubes. His paper describes passing a discharge from an induction coil through a Hittorf vacuum tube or a well-exhausted Crookes' or Lenard's tube. The Museum of Radiation and Radioactivity at Oak Ridge Associated Universities says the Coolidge tube did not replace cold-cathode tubes at once: they were manufactured into the 1920s, saw routine use into the 1930s, and there were instances of their use in radiology as late as the 1960s.

Coolidge's change

William David Coolidge, an American physicist at General Electric, introduced a hot-cathode X-ray tube in 1913, according to the Smithsonian. ORAU calls its invention "the single most important event in the progress of radiology". Its defining features are a high vacuum, so little gas that it takes no part in making X-rays, and a heated filament as the source of electrons.

A black and white photograph of a glass X-ray tube with a large round central bulb and two long narrow side arms ending in metal caps.
A Coolidge X-ray tube with a heated cathode, made by British Thomson-Houston Ltd. The large bulb limits heat and tungsten deposits on the glass. Photo: Wellcome Collection, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

How it makes X-rays

When the cathode filament is heated it emits electrons, and the hotter it gets the more it emits. A high voltage between the cathode and the positively charged anode accelerates the electrons. When they hit the anode they change direction and emit bremsstrahlung, X-rays with a continuous range of energies, and the maximum energy of those X-rays equals the kinetic energy of the electrons. ORAU adds that stray radiation is also produced when electrons hit other tube components.

Four boxes in a row: heated filament, high voltage, tungsten target, beam out.
How an X-ray tube makes X-rays. Original IOI diagram.

Two controls, not one

ORAU says the key advantages are stability and that the intensity and energy of the X-rays can be controlled independently. More filament current raises the filament temperature, which means more electrons and a more intense beam. More voltage means faster electrons and more energetic X-rays. A doctor could now choose both, which the gas tube had not allowed.

Tungsten and heat

Tungsten is the most common target material because it has a high atomic number, which increases X-ray intensity, and a melting point high enough that it can be allowed to become white hot. The target may reach 2,700 degrees Celsius in operation, ORAU says, and is often surrounded by copper, whose high heat capacity helps dissipate heat. Radiopaedia states that in a typical diagnostic tube only about 1 per cent of the electron energy becomes radiation and about 99 per cent becomes heat, which it calls the undesirable product; the split depends on the tube voltage. Some cracking and pitting of the focal spot is normal, and a tungsten-rhenium alloy has been used to reduce both, ORAU notes.

Why the bulb is large

The bulb of a Coolidge tube is large to increase the surface through which heat radiates, which limits the glass temperature. Its size also reduces the amount of tungsten that can be deposited per unit area, and it keeps the glass away from the strongest part of the electric field. If the tube has another way of losing heat, the bulb can be smaller.

A line diagram of a rotating-anode X-ray tube inside an evacuated glass bottle, labelled with stator, rotor, bearings, tungsten-rhenium anode, thin exit window, filament and focusing cup, and cathode support.
Parts of a rotating-anode X-ray tube: the anode turns on a rotor driven by an outside stator, and the filament sits in a focusing cup. Photo: Kieranmaher, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The focal spot

The filament sits in a cylindrical slot in the cathode, and the focal spot on the anode is similar in size and shape to that slot. Moving the filament deeper into the slot shrinks the focal spot, and moving it closer to the top enlarges it. Radiopaedia lists the working parts of a modern tube: the filament that boils off electrons, the target, and an anode rotor with an induction stator. The diagram above shows these parts labelled.

Where it leads

For what the beam then does, see how X-ray machines work. For the tube's earliest history, see the history of the X-ray machine.

Quick answers

What did Coolidge change about the X-ray tube?

In 1913 he introduced a high-vacuum tube with a heated filament as the source of electrons. This made the beam stable and let intensity and energy be controlled separately.

Why is tungsten used in X-ray tubes?

It has a high atomic number, which raises X-ray intensity, and a high enough melting point to run white hot.

How much of the energy becomes X-rays?

In a typical diagnostic tube, Radiopaedia puts it at about 1 per cent, with about 99 per cent becoming heat; the split depends on the tube voltage.

Sources

The 1913 date is from the Smithsonian; the primary Coolidge paper (Physical Review 1914; British Journal of Radiology 1914) was not opened. Design features, control, tungsten, the 2,700 C figure, bulb size and focal spot are from ORAU. The 99 per cent heat share and the parts of a modern tube are from Radiopaedia. Röntgen's tube types are from the Science translation of his paper. The article does not explain why the anode rotates because the sources read do not say.

More from this book

History · From the book The X-ray Machine

The history of the X-ray machine: Röntgen's discovery in 1895

X-rays were found by accident, by a physicist studying something else.

Explainer · From the book The X-ray Machine

How X-ray machines work

An X-ray image is a shadow.

History · From the book The X-ray Machine

X-ray mobile units in World War 1: Marie Curie's petites Curies

In 1914 X-ray machines were in hospitals, not at the front.

Explainer · From the book The X-ray Machine

How much radiation is in an X-ray? Doses compared

The radiation in an X-ray is real but small, and it is measured against the radiation everyone gets from the ground, the air and space.