Cover of The Skyscraper, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book The Skyscraper
Chapters 9 and 10. Read the full book free as a PDF.

Wind grows faster than height

A Princeton study of the Hancock Center says that the controlling factor in the design of multistorey buildings is usually the sideways load from wind. It describes Khan's "structural height premium": the extra material needed to resist lateral loads, over and above what gravity alone requires, which grows as a building gets taller. In a plain steel frame, you pay a rising price in steel for every extra floor.

The tube idea

According to Wikipedia, Khan, who was born in Dhaka in 1929 and joined SOM in Chicago in 1955, proposed using all the outer wall of a building to act like a thin-walled tube. It names framed, trussed and bundled tube variants. It says that tubes are stiff, use less material, and can be built in steel, reinforced concrete or a mix. That last claim is general-reference wording, not a measured count.

The Hancock Center: braces on the outside

The Princeton study says the Hancock Center is a 100-storey, 1,127-foot steel tower in Chicago by SOM, and was the tallest building in the world outside New York at the time. It gives the completion year as 1968 in the text and 1969 in a data line, so dates for this building vary by source.

The study says SOM's first calculations showed that a framed tube for this tower would take too much steel. Khan then proposed tying the exterior columns together with diagonals. It explains that, in a plain framed tube, only 30% of the sideways deflection comes from cantilever action and 70% from frame action, while the braced Hancock behaves much more like a true cantilever, much as in Khan's own analysis. The diagonals also spread the weight of the building more evenly across the columns.

Looking up at a tall black tapering tower with large diagonal steel braces visible across its face, against a blue sky.
The John Hancock Center, Chicago (photographed 2011). The diagonal braces on the outside are part of the structure. Photo: Joe Ravi, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Wind and the Burj

The Burj Khalifa's owner says its Y-shaped plan was used to shape the structural core, helps reduce wind forces, and that the structural system is a "buttressed core". Different shape, same problem: stiffness against wind.

Why this matters

A tube turns the outside of the building, which is already needed for windows and walls, into the structure. That is why Khan's work is tied to the economics of height as much as to engineering. For how the type started see the first skyscraper, and for how height is measured, how tall is the Burj Khalifa.

Quick answers

Who invented the tube structure for skyscrapers?

Fazlur Rahman Khan, a structural engineer at Skidmore, Owings and Merrill in Chicago, is credited with the tube systems, including the framed, trussed and bundled tube.

Why are there diagonal braces on the Hancock Center?

They tie the outer columns together so the walls act as a stiff tube, which resists wind with less steel than a plain framed tube would need, according to a Princeton study.

Is wind or weight the bigger design problem for a tall building?

For very tall buildings, sideways wind load usually controls the design, according to the Princeton study.

Go deeper in the book: The Skyscraper · PDF · Source Companion · Browse the category

Sources

The 30%/70% deflection split, the height premium, the 100 storeys, 1,127 feet and the 1968/1969 dates are from the Princeton Hancock Center study. Khan's biography, the tube variants and the 40-storey statement are from Wikipedia. The Y-shaped plan and buttressed core are from the Burj Khalifa owner's page. The Sears/Willis Tower is not covered because no source on it was read for this article.

More from this book

History · From the book The Skyscraper

What was the first skyscraper? The Home Insurance Building and the argument around it

The first skyscraper is usually said to be the Home Insurance Building in Chicago, designed in 1884 by William Le Baron Jenney and finished in 1885.

Technology · From the book The Skyscraper

How the elevator made the skyscraper possible: Otis, the safety brake and 1857

A tall building is useless if people will not ride to the top.

Records · From the book The Skyscraper

How tall is the Burj Khalifa? 828 metres, and the three ways to measure a tower

Burj Khalifa is 828 metres (2,716.5 feet) tall.

Law and form · From the book The Skyscraper

Why New York skyscrapers step back: the Equitable Building and the 1916 zoning law

The Equitable Building at 120 Broadway opened in 1915 as the world's largest office building by floor area.