Law and form · Industrials · Construction and Engineering
Why New York skyscrapers step back: the Equitable Building and the 1916 zoning law
The Equitable Building at 120 Broadway opened in 1915 as the world's largest office building by floor area. It rose from the street line with no setbacks and shut out light from its neighbours. That row helped lead to the 1916 Zoning Resolution, the first modern limits on tall buildings in Manhattan.
From the book The SkyscraperChapter 14. Read the full book free as a PDF.
The building
Wikipedia's article describes the Equitable Building as a 38-storey, 555-foot (169 m) tower with 1.2 million square feet of floor space, built from 1913 to 1915 for an estimated $29 million. It replaced the Equitable Life Building, which burned down in 1912. The count of 38 floors is complicated: the article says the total includes penthouses and two interior floors, so the exterior shows 36 storeys and 525 feet.
It covers the entire block bounded by Broadway, Cedar, Nassau and Pine streets. Because the plot is big and the tower rises from the street, the upper floors have an H-shaped plan of 30,000 square feet each, with two light courts cut into the sides above the seventh floor.

No setbacks, on purpose
The article says that the architect Ernest R. Graham wanted the latest elevators, heating, ventilation and fireproofing, and to maximise usable office space. The sources do not state the owner's finances, but the building's design follows from that goal: more floor area means more rentable space.
Why it was controversial
On completion the building was controversial because it had no setbacks, which stopped sunlight from reaching the ground around it. Wikipedia states this contributed to the 1916 Zoning Resolution, the first modern building and zoning limits on vertical structures in Manhattan. The resolution tied the permitted height of a building to the width of the street it faced, required upper floors to step back as they rose, and allowed a tower to rise without those limits on a quarter of the lot.
What came out of it
The stepped silhouette that people associate with older New York towers is a response to rules about light and air, not just a style. A rule prompted by one building shaped how many later towers were drawn. That is how law shapes a skyline, which the book covers in its chapter on law and the skyline. For the structure side of height see how skyscrapers resist wind, and for the first tall frames, the first skyscraper.
Quick answers
Why do old New York skyscrapers have setbacks?
The 1916 Zoning Resolution required them. Wikipedia says the Equitable Building, which had none and blocked sunlight, contributed to its adoption.
How tall is the Equitable Building?
555 feet (169 m) with 38 stories counting penthouses and two interior floors, or 525 feet over 36 visible storeys, according to Wikipedia.
When was the Equitable Building completed?
On 1 May 1915, according to Wikipedia.
