Manufacturing · Consumer Discretionary · Automobiles
The Toyota Production System: how lean production works and why it breaks
Toyota built a way of making cars from poverty and a rejection of Ford's batches. It rests on two ideas: make only what is needed when it is needed, and stop at once when something is wrong. It made Toyota the largest carmaker in the world, and it left the industry exposed to shocks.
From the book The Motor Car: Machine, Industry, WorldChapters 15 to 17 and 42. Read the full book free as a PDF.
Two pillars
Toyota's own account of the Toyota Production System is short. It describes a way of making things that is based on making work easier for workers, with the objective of eliminating waste and shortening lead times so vehicles reach customers quickly, cheaply and with high quality. It stands on two pillars. The first is jidoka, which Toyota translates loosely as "automation with a human touch": a machine or a person stops the line at once when something abnormal is detected, so defects are not passed on. The second is Just-in-Time: making only what is needed, when it is needed, and in the amount needed, with all processes linked in a continuous flow.
Jidoka: stopping on purpose
In Toyota's description, a machine that detects an abnormality stops automatically, or the operator pulls a stop cord and the andon board lights up to tell people where. Workers need only respond when something is wrong, which also removes the need for a person to watch a machine. Toyota says this builds quality into the process itself, by finding the problem where it happens and preventing it from coming back. The company adds that a process must first be done properly by hand, with waste, unevenness and unreasonable demands removed, before it is handed to a machine. It calls the daily small improvements that do this kaizen.
The book describes the same inversion in plain terms. A classic mass-production plant tolerated defects at the end of the line, where rectification bays fixed what the system had made wrong. Lean production treats every defect as a stoppage and every stoppage as a question, asking why five times down to the root, so that a line grows more reliable the more it is stopped.
Just-in-Time: pulling, not pushing
Toyota's history site credits the idea to its founder's son, Kiichiro Toyoda, who proposed Just-in-Time when the Koromo Plant opened; his principle was that there should be neither shortage nor excess. Toyota says that a car contains more than 30,000 parts, many made by partner companies, so all plants must work in step. Each stage keeps only the minimum stock of parts needed, and the stage before it holds a store of finished parts from which the next stage takes what it needs. Production runs at the pace of sales.
Toyota's own account of the Toyota Production System rests on two pillars: just-in-time and jidoka, automation with a human touch.
What the MIT study found
In 1990 a team at MIT published The Machine That Changed the World and named the system lean production. The Christian Science Monitor, reviewing it in November 1990, quoted the authors that lean production "uses less of everything compared with mass production - half the human effort in the factory, half the manufacturing space, half the investment in tools, half the engineering hours to develop a new product in half the time".
The commercial result was clear by 2008. The Washington Post, reporting in January 2009, said Toyota had taken the title of world's largest automaker from General Motors, the first time in 77 years, selling 8.972 million cars and trucks in 2008 against GM's 8.356 million.
The fragile side of lean
A supply chain tuned to hours of stock has no cushion. AlixPartners forecast in September 2021 that 7.7 million units of vehicle production would be lost that year, with $210 billion in lost revenue for the industry, and said chips were one of many disruptions. Lean did not cause the shortage, but a system designed to hold little stock turns any missing part into a stopped line. The book also notes that relentless kaizen has human costs and critics, as the moving line had.
For the system lean replaced, see Ford's moving assembly line, and for the pay and labour problem that preceded it, the five-dollar day.
Quick answers
What is the Toyota Production System?
A way of making cars built on two pillars: Just-in-Time, which makes only what is needed when it is needed, and jidoka, which stops production the moment an abnormality is detected. Toyota describes the aim as eliminating waste and shortening lead times.
What is jidoka?
Toyota translates it loosely as automation with a human touch. A machine, or an operator pulling a stop cord, halts the line when something is wrong, so defective products are not passed on.
When did Toyota overtake General Motors?
In 2008, according to the Washington Post: Toyota sold 8.972 million vehicles to GM's 8.356 million, the first time in 77 years that GM was not the largest.
Sources
- Toyota Motor Corporation, Toyota Production System
- Toyota Motor Corporation, 75 Years of Toyota: Kiichiro Toyoda proposes Just-in-Time at the Koromo Plant
- Christian Science Monitor, 28 November 1990: review of The Machine That Changed the World
- Washington Post, 22 January 2009: Toyota passes General Motors as world's largest carmaker
- AlixPartners, 23 September 2021: semiconductor shortages to cost the auto industry $210 billion
- Toyota Motor Corporation, Toyota Production System
