Technology · Consumer Discretionary · Automobiles
Why gasoline beat electric cars in the 1900s, and what it says about batteries
In 1900 the electric car was not a curiosity. The census counted more electric cars than petrol cars. Within a generation it had almost vanished from passenger roads, and the reasons were range, a cheap universal car, and a battery that always seemed about to improve.
From the book The Motor Car: Machine, Industry, WorldChapters 5, 8 and 37. Read the full book free as a PDF.
The 1900 count
The US Census Bureau counted motor vehicles for the first time in 1900. The Richmond Federal Reserve, summarising the data, reports that 109 manufacturers built 1,681 steam cars, 1,575 electric cars and only 936 with internal combustion engines. The electric car was a leading technology, not a rival from the margin. The census numbers above give about 38 percent electric (1,575 of 4,192) of US vehicles built in 1900, a share of production rather than of vehicles on the road.
Why electrics led early
The Richmond Fed quotes the business historian David Kirsch: if you had surveyed engineers in 1900 they would have said they were waiting for a battery breakthrough and then electric cars would be everywhere, and that internal combustion would stay a sideline of no more than about 2 percent. The reasons were sensible. Electric trolleys had changed cities from 1888. Early cars were used mostly for short city trips and deliveries, where electrics were at their best. City streets were crowded with horses and the roads beyond them were bad, which blunted the petrol car's range advantage.
The Smithsonian adds the consumer side. Electric cars such as the 1900 Riker, 1904 Columbia runabout and 1914 Rauch and Lang were simple to operate, clean, quiet and comfortable, and a sizeable market grew among wealthy urban women. They were also expensive, and electricity was expensive.

What went wrong for electrics
The Smithsonian lists the limits: an electric car did not run far between charges, its lead-acid batteries needed frequent maintenance, and electricity was not available across most of rural America until the 1930s, when Americans already wanted to travel. Most buyers in the 1910s and 1920s chose petrol cars, which were far from perfect but had much longer range between fill-ups. Filling stations could be put anywhere.
The Richmond Fed describes an episode that damaged electrics. The Electric Vehicle Company, formed in 1899, planned to run 12,000 electric cabs in big US cities. About 2,000 were built, according to the historian John Rae, but they were clumsy and expensive to run, with batteries that weighed a ton and were exchanged for charged ones after each trip. The press called it the Lead Cab Trust, and the company defaulted in 1907. Kirsch says its failure was blamed largely, perhaps unfairly, on electric vehicle technology.
The battery that was always coming
Kirsch also argues that the market was shaped by expectation. Thomas Edison announced in 1901 that he was on the brink of a breakthrough, and his iron-nickel battery was better, and costlier, than lead-acid, but nothing like a miracle, and did not reach the market until 1909. In the meantime, Kirsch says, many would-be electric buyers bought nothing or a petrol car. A magazine reported in September 1902, from the 1900 census, that gasoline had taken the lead in output.
The Model T and the starter
The Richmond Fed notes that Olds Motor Works built more than 5,000 low-priced Oldsmobiles in 1904, more than the whole output of electrics and steamers combined. In 1908 Ford began selling the Model T for about $850, and it made it virtually impossible for electrics to compete for the mass market. By 1914, the Fed says, electric vehicles had lost nearly all their market share. The Smithsonian points to a 1913 Model T in its collection with an electric starter in place of a crank, a retrofit made by an owner rather than a factory fit, which combined the ease of an electric with the range of petrol. Ford's own history page gives the Model T's starting price as $825 in 1908, so figures of $825 and $850 both circulate.
The lesson
Electric vehicles never disappeared completely. The Richmond Fed notes that electric delivery trucks survived into the 1920s and electric golf carts and forklifts became dominant in their own places. The book draws the lesson that the electric drivetrain was never the problem; the battery was. For the history of the technology that finally changed that, see who invented the lithium-ion battery. For the system that made petrol cars cheap, see Ford's moving assembly line.
Quick answers
Why did electric cars lose to gasoline cars?
Range, cost and convenience. Electric cars of the 1900s had short range and heavy lead-acid batteries, electricity was not widely available in rural areas, and Ford's mass-produced Model T made petrol cars cheap. The electric starter removed the petrol car's main inconvenience.
Were there more electric cars than gasoline cars in 1900?
Yes, among US vehicles built in 1900 by the census count: 1,575 electric against 936 internal combustion, with 1,681 steam, according to the Richmond Fed. This counts production, not vehicles registered or on the road.
When did electric cars disappear?
By 1914 electric vehicles had lost nearly all their market share to internal combustion cars, according to the Richmond Fed, though electric delivery trucks survived into the 1920s.
