Cover of Whisky, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book Whisky
Chapters 5 to 8. Read the full book free as a PDF.

The principle

All stills use one fact: water, alcohol and the flavour compounds in the wash vaporise at different temperatures. Difford's Guide notes that ethanol and water form a mixture of about 95.6 per cent alcohol, boiling at 78.1 degrees Celsius, that cannot be separated further by distillation. That is far above what whisky makers want. Whisky is distilled to leave flavour in.

The pot still

Difford's describes a pot still as a chamber heated from below. The contents boil, the vapour collects in the head and is directed into a tapering swan neck. Pot stills have changed little in hundreds of years, and the main advance is heating by controlled steam instead of a direct fire. They are, Difford's says, inefficient users of energy and limited by batch operation. Each batch is charged, run, emptied and cleaned before the next. Because the run is controlled by the operator, he or she can make the cuts between heads, hearts and tails, as in the Scotch spirit safe.

A large copper pot still with a rounded base and tapering neck inside a still house.
One of the smaller copper pot stills at the Jameson distillery in Midleton, County Cork, photographed in 2014. Photo: Chris Gorringe, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

The column still

A column still runs continuously. In the Coffey design, wash enters near the top and falls through perforated floors while steam rises from the bottom. Alcohol is lower-boiling and goes up with the steam, and the water and solids fall. Difford's says early column stills had two columns and modern ones can have as many as seven. In a four-column arrangement the first column, the analyser, strips the alcohol to make high wines of 65 to 70 per cent. The second and third columns rectify and the fourth recovers spirit from the heads and tails. Vacuum can push the output to 95.6 per cent, the azeotrope.

A tall column still built in sections, standing in a museum still house.
A Coffey (column) still at Kilbeggan distillery, County Westmeath, Ireland. Photo: HighKing, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Who invented it

Difford's gives Robert Stein's two-column still as 1826, with Aeneas Coffey improving the design and patenting it in 1831. The Oxford Companion to Spirits and Cocktails and the book give Stein's still as 1828 and Coffey's patent as 1830. ScotchWhisky.com says Coffey applied for the patent in 1830. A notice in Dingler's Polytechnisches Journal records that Coffey received the patent in 1831. So 1830 is the application and 1831 the grant. Coffey was an excise officer who retired from the service and then built the machine. ScotchWhisky.com calls him "gamekeeper turned poacher".

What the law allows

The law sets limits for both machines. Scotch must be distilled to less than 94.8 per cent alcohol so that it keeps the aroma and taste of its raw materials. US whisky must be distilled at less than 95 per cent. Bourbon must come off at 160 proof (80 per cent) or less. A column still can be run lighter and a pot still heavier, but a single-malt Scotch must be made in pot stills, and Irish pot still whiskey must be batch distilled in pot stills.

Cost and control

Distiller magazine's Scott Schiller, who says he has launched over 50 distilleries, puts the trade-off simply: the pot still offers more control and a greater diversity of spirits, while the column offers speed, efficiency and consistency. He gives a well-made 500-gallon pot still at $180,000 to $250,000 and a 12-inch column still at about $225,000. His chart has the column nearly four times more efficient per operator. Pot-still spirit, he adds, is generally accepted to give a palatable bourbon in two years, while a column spirit needs more time.

Copper in both

Copper reacts with sulphur compounds and removes them, Waterford Whisky says. Alcademics adds that a column still can be stainless steel but needs copper where the vapour is refined, in bubble-cap plates or packing. So the question of copper is separate from the question of pot or column.

Blending the two

Most Scotch and Irish blends combine pot still malt and column-still grain whisky. The Irish technical file says the column gives a lighter spirit and pot stills a more fully flavoured one, and that grain whisky is distilled in column stills. For an Irish example, see how Irish whiskey and Jameson are made. For the full sequence, see how whisky is made.

Quick answers

What is the difference between a pot still and a column still?

A pot still runs in batches and keeps more flavour compounds. A column still runs continuously and can make a lighter, cleaner spirit at lower cost.

Who invented the column still?

Robert Stein built an early two-column still and Aeneas Coffey improved it. Coffey applied for a patent in 1830 and was granted it in 1831.

Is single malt made in a column still?

No. Single malt Scotch must be made in pot stills at a single distillery.

Go deeper in the book: Whisky · PDF · Source Companion · Browse the category

Sources

Pot and column descriptions, the 65 to 70 per cent analyser output and the 95.6 per cent azeotrope are from Difford's Guide. Dates conflict between sources: Difford's gives Stein 1826 and Coffey 1831; the Oxford Companion (as cited in the book) gives Stein 1828 and Coffey 1830. The 1831 grant is from Dingler's Journal; the 1830 application is from ScotchWhisky.com. Cost and efficiency figures are one distilling consultant's estimates, not an industry standard. Legal strength limits are from the Scotch regulations and 27 CFR 5.143. The book's statement that Coffey's patent was in 1830 is therefore the application year.

More from this book

Explainer · From the book Whisky

How whisky is made, from grain to bottle

Whisky is grain, water and yeast that has been fermented, distilled and left in wood.

Explainer · From the book Whisky

How Scotch whisky is made, and what the law requires

Scotch is not a style.

Explainer · From the book Whisky

How bourbon is made, and what the federal rules say

Bourbon is defined by a short list of federal rules.

Explainer · From the book Whisky

How Irish whiskey is made, and how Jameson is made

Irish whiskey has a written technical file with four stages and four legal styles.