Cover of The Lithium-ion Battery: Ion, Cell, Charge, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book The Lithium-ion Battery: Ion, Cell, Charge
Chapter 12. Read the full book free as a PDF.

The bargain in the chemistry

The high voltage that makes the battery useful needs an organic electrolyte, and organic electrolytes are fuel. Energy can escape slowly, as the cell ages and dies, or all at once. All at once is called thermal runaway. EPRI, the US power-industry research institute, explains that thermal runaway is not the same as ignition: it is the irreversible failure of the cell that produces flammable gases, and the gases may or may not then ignite.

Staircase diagram of thermal runaway in five steps: abuse, breakdown of the anode film, separator failure, oxygen release from the cathode, and ignition of vent gas with spread to the next cell.
How a cell goes into thermal runaway. Original IOI diagram, simplified.

What starts it

EPRI lists the abuse conditions that can trigger thermal runaway: short circuits, mechanical damage, overcharging or over-discharging, and overheating. As the cell heats, the protective film on the anode, the SEI, breaks down and the electrolyte reacts with the anode. EPRI also notes that as temperature rises the cathode starts to break down and release oxygen, which reacts with the electrolyte solvents. Depending on the chemistry, the cell can then carry part of its own oxidiser; lithium iron phosphate releases far less oxygen than nickel-rich cathodes. That is one reason such fires can be hard to put out and can reignite.

The cell builds pressure and ejects hot aerosols and flammable gas at high speed. The vent gases include carbon monoxide, methane, ethylene and ethane, according to EPRI, and the binder in the electrodes can release hydrogen fluoride. If heat reaches neighbouring cells, the failure moves through the module and pack.

Why early warning is hard

The weak point is early warning. A NIST paper on thermal runaway mitigation notes that conventional smoke and heat detectors are not designed for the first stage, because initial venting and off-gassing give off little smoke and a weak heat signature before ignition, so ignition can come before anyone is warned. Researchers have therefore tried detection based on cell surface temperature, internal temperature, voltage and current. In NIST's single-cell tests, the time of intervention, the cutoff temperature and the rate at which temperature rises identified thresholds that separated runs with no ignition from runs with delayed ignition. The authors say this applies only to single cells under natural convection, so it is a framework for timing a response, not a proven pack-level fix. For how cathode chemistry changes the picture, see LFP vs NMC.

2006: the laptop recalls

The industry's best-known manufacturing failure is the 2006 laptop recall. The US Consumer Product Safety Commission announced that Dell was recalling 4.1 million notebook batteries because they could overheat and cause fires, the largest consumer-electronics safety recall to that date.

The sequence, in order

EPRI lays out how a cell fails, and the order matters. Heat accumulates. The solid electrolyte film on the anode breaks down, releasing carbon dioxide, and the electrolyte is exposed to the anode, which reforms the film and decomposes more electrolyte, producing flammable hydrocarbons and more heat. Then the polymer separator melts, allowing an internal short circuit and still more heat. As temperatures rise the cathode of some chemistries breaks down and releases oxygen, which reacts with the electrolyte solvents to form carbon dioxide, fluoride gases and hydrocarbons. Last, the binder holding the electrodes together breaks down and releases hydrogen fluoride. A NIST paper on early detection groups the same process into heating, pressure relief, thermal runaway and weakening stages.

Runaway is not the same as fire

EPRI draws a line that news reports often blur. Thermal runaway is the irreversible failure that produces flammable gas. Whether a fire or explosion follows depends on whether that gas meets air in the right proportions. A swollen phone battery has formed gas inside the cell, which can happen with or without thermal runaway. At the McMicken storage site in Surprise, Arizona, one rack went into runaway and filled its container with gas that was initially too rich to burn. When first responders opened the doors, the air let in allowed the gas to ignite. In FM Global tests on identical lithium iron phosphate modules overheated with no external flame, ignition of the vented gas was unpredictable even in the laboratory. That last point matters for the claim that one chemistry is simply safe: the gas still vents.

How common are fires?

Fires are rare against the number of cells made, but they are not zero and large installations make them visible. EPRI's database had recorded 56 stationary energy storage failure events worldwide from 2011 to December 2022, of which 49 occurred since 2018. That count rises with the number of systems installed. The sensible reading is that the risk is managed rather than removed, and that the safest cell design is a different chemistry or a better pack, not a better warning label.

Per cell, EPRI cites estimates of failure over a cell's lifetime of about 1 in 10 million (a 2006 source) or 1 in 40 million (a 2011 source), and says both need updating. Scale changes the picture. A representative electric-car pack built from 18650 cells can hold about 8,000 of them, so even a very small per-cell rate is multiplied across a pack. EPRI counts 10,584 cells in the 2 MW Arizona battery, about 6.5 million in a 20 MW, 80 MWh plant in California and about 5.5 million in a 300 MW, 1,200 MWh plant in the same state. For the history of how the first lithium cells had the same problem, see who invented the lithium-ion battery.

Quick answers

What is thermal runaway in a lithium-ion battery?

It is the irreversible failure of a cell in which heat-driven reactions produce flammable gases and more heat. It does not always lead to a fire, but it can.

Why are lithium-ion battery fires hard to put out?

In some chemistries a hot cathode can release oxygen, and the electrolyte is flammable, so the fire can be hard to smother and can restart after it seems to have gone out.

What triggers thermal runaway?

Short circuits, crushing or other mechanical damage, overcharging, over-discharging and overheating, according to EPRI.

Sources

The definition of thermal runaway, triggers, oxygen release from the cathode, vent gases, hydrogen fluoride and the failure-database count are from EPRI. The 4.1 million Dell recall is from the CPSC. The contamination cause and the list of safety measures follow Chapter 12 of the book. The failure sequence, McMicken, FM Global tests, per-cell failure estimates and cell counts are from EPRI, and the oxygen release varies with cathode chemistry; the four stages are from the NIST paper.

More from this book

History · From the book The Lithium-ion Battery: Ion, Cell, Charge

Who invented the lithium-ion battery? Whittingham, Goodenough, Yoshino and Sony

No single person invented the lithium-ion battery.

Explainer · From the book The Lithium-ion Battery: Ion, Cell, Charge

How a lithium-ion battery works: the rocking-chair cell explained

A lithium-ion cell has no lithium metal inside it.

Supply chain · From the book The Lithium-ion Battery: Ion, Cell, Charge

Where does lithium for batteries come from? Mines, brines and the cobalt question

Lithium is not rare in the ground.

Chemistry and cost · From the book The Lithium-ion Battery: Ion, Cell, Charge

LFP vs NMC batteries: why the cheaper chemistry is winning

For most of the 2010s, lithium iron phosphate lost to denser chemistries.