Cover of The Natural Gas Pipeline: Steel, Pressure, Flow, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book The Natural Gas Pipeline: Steel, Pressure, Flow
Chapter 11. Read the full book free as a PDF.

The problem

Natural gas is mostly methane, which has no smell. A leak can fill a room or a crawl space without anyone noticing, until something ignites it. The book states the problem plainly: a fuel that can kill by explosion or by asphyxiation needs a way to be noticed.

New London, 18 March 1937

New London was in the East Texas oilfield, and its school district was one of the richest rural districts in the United States. The Texas State Historical Association records that on 18 March 1937, at 3:05 p.m., an instructor turned on a sanding machine in an area filled with a mixture of gas and air. The spark ignited it and carried the flame into a nearly enclosed space under the building, 253 feet long and 56 feet wide. The building lifted. Of about 500 students and 40 teachers in the building, approximately 298 died.

Black and white press photograph of men in hats and work clothes carrying debris out of a collapsed brick and timber school building, with an AP Wirephoto mark in the corner.
Rescuers at the New London, Texas, school after the explosion of 18 March 1937. A press photograph; the photographer is not named. Photo: Unknown (press photograph), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Where the gas came from

Inquiries found that until 18 January 1937 the school had bought its gas from the United Gas Company. To save $300 a month, the association says, plumbers, with the knowledge and approval of the school board and the superintendent, had tapped a residue gas line of a nearby gasoline company. Using "green" or "wet" gas from such lines was a common money-saving practice in the oilfield for homes, schools and churches. Researchers concluded that gas escaped from a faulty connection and collected beneath the building. Green gas has no smell, so nobody had a warning.

The cause was not a single failure. The gas was untreated, the connection leaked, the leak had nowhere to go, and nothing in the product told anyone it was there. The book makes the same point when it says no one smelled a leak because the gas had no odour.

The law

The association calls the most important result of the disaster a state odorisation law requiring distinctive malodorants to be mixed into gas for commercial and industrial use so people could be warned by smell. The Homeland Security Digital Library identifies it as House Bill 1017 of the 45th Texas Legislature, passed in 1937.

What is added now

Gas distributors add an odorant, a sulphur compound with a strong smell, at a concentration that makes a leak noticeable well below the level at which it could burn. The specific compounds and concentrations vary by operator and country, and this article does not list them. The point that matters is the design principle: the warning has to be noticeable at a fraction of the dangerous level, in every building the gas reaches.

Odorant is a warning for people near a leak. Operators also watch their pipes by other means. See how operators inspect a pipe from inside, and what four ruptures taught regulators.

Quick answers

Why does natural gas smell?

Natural gas is nearly odourless. A strong-smelling compound is added so leaks can be noticed. The practice became law in Texas after the New London school explosion of 18 March 1937.

How many people died in the New London school explosion?

Approximately 298, out of about 500 students and 40 teachers in the building, according to the Handbook of Texas.

What caused the New London explosion?

Gas from an untreated residue gas line, tapped to save money, leaked from a faulty connection and collected under the school. It had no odour, so no one noticed. A sanding machine switch ignited it.

Sources

The date, time, building dimensions, death toll (approximately 298), the $300-a-month saving, the residue gas line, green gas without smell, and the odorisation law are from the Handbook of Texas (TSHA). House Bill 1017 of 1937 is from the Homeland Security Digital Library. Some other sources give a slightly different time of day (about 3:17 p.m.), so the time is attributed to TSHA.

More from this book

Engineering · From the book The Natural Gas Pipeline: Steel, Pressure, Flow

Why gas pipelines need compressor stations: pressure, friction and the sawtooth

A gas pipeline does not push gas the way a pump pushes water.

Inspection · From the book The Natural Gas Pipeline: Steel, Pressure, Flow

What is a pipeline pig? How operators inspect a gas pipe from inside

You cannot dig up a thousand kilometres of pipe to look at it.

Safety · From the book The Natural Gas Pipeline: Steel, Pressure, Flow

Gas pipeline explosions: what San Bruno, Carlsbad and Natchitoches taught regulators

A pipeline failure releases a great deal at once.

Trade · From the book The Natural Gas Pipeline: Steel, Pressure, Flow

Pipeline or LNG ship? How natural gas gets to market

A pipeline is fixed and a tanker is not.