Cover of The Air Conditioner: Ice, Vapor, Empire, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book The Air Conditioner: Ice, Vapor, Empire
Chapters 7 and 21. Read the full book free as a PDF.

The dangerous first fluids

The early industry used what worked thermally, and much of it was vicious: ammonia, sulfur dioxide, methyl chloride. These machines cooled well and, when they leaked, poisoned the room. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's refrigerant safety history records the toll: fatal leaks in the 1920s, including a much-discussed hospital accident, made "safety refrigerant" a commercial necessity rather than a slogan.

Midgley's miracle: Freon

General Motors' Frigidaire division put Thomas Midgley on the problem. In a few days of systematic searching through the periodic table, his team landed on dichlorodifluoromethane, CFC-12, sold as Freon: non-flammable, low in toxicity, stable, and thermally excellent. Midgley demonstrated it before the American Chemical Society in 1930 by inhaling the vapour and snuffing a candle with his breath. The chlorofluorocarbons and their HCFC cousins made the home refrigerator and the room air conditioner safe enough to sell by the million, and for forty years the question seemed settled.

The ozone reckoning

In 1974 Mario Molina and Sherwood Rowland published their hypothesis in Nature: CFCs are so stable that they drift intact to the stratosphere, where ultraviolet light frees their chlorine, and each chlorine atom destroys ozone catalytically. The Antarctic ozone hole, found in 1985, proved them right in the most public way. The response was the 1987 Montreal Protocol, which the UN Environment Programme counts as the most successful environmental treaty: about 99 percent of ozone-depleting substances have been phased out, and the ozone layer is healing.

The bridge: R-22 and the HCFC years

Montreal did not flip a switch; it built a staircase. CFCs went first, and the industry crossed on HCFCs, above all R-22, the working fluid of a generation of home air conditioners: kinder to ozone, not innocent of it, and itself later phased down. Each step down the staircase cost the industry a re-engineering, because a refrigerant is not a drop-in fluid. Compressor oils, seals, pressures, safety classes and charge sizes all change with the molecule, which is why the treaty timelines run in decades and why old machines still in service matter so much.

The climate catch

The substitutes, HFCs, carry no chlorine and spare the ozone, but they are powerful greenhouse gases, thousands of times CO2 by weight for some, and they leak by the kilogram from every charged machine and every scrapped unit. So the treaty machinery turned again: the 2016 Kigali Amendment to the Montreal Protocol phases HFCs down, with the Ozone Secretariat's ratification list now tracking more than 160 parties. UNEP estimates the full phase-down avoids up to 0.4 degrees Celsius of warming this century.

A modern split-type air conditioner indoor unit mounted high on a wall
The indoor half of a split-system air conditioner. The noisy condenser sits outside, joined by refrigerant lines through the wall. Photo: Curpharar, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What the buyer can do

Three ordinary choices decide most of a household's refrigerant footprint. Buy the lower-warming fluid where it is offered. Maintain the machine, because a sealed system should never need gas and every top-up is a leak. And at the end of its life, hand the unit to a channel that recovers the refrigerant instead of crushing it with the charge inside. The chemistry is negotiated in treaty halls; the leaks are decided at the curb.

The bank problem

The molecules already sold do not retire when the rules change. Every charged machine and every stockpiled cylinder is a bank of refrigerant, and the bank leaks: through seals, through careless service, and at the scrapyard when a unit is crushed with its charge still inside. Recovery and destruction of these banks is unglamorous plumbing, but in climate terms it is among the cheapest large tonnages of greenhouse gas available anywhere. The Kigali machinery knows it, and the collection and destruction of old gas has become an industry of its own.

The fourth generation

Two answers are competing. One is a new synthetic family, the HFOs, with atmospheric lifetimes of days. The other is a return to the old naturals: propane and isobutane in small charges, carbon dioxide in supermarkets, ammonia where it always stayed, in industry. In between sits R-32, a single-component HFC with about a third of the warming power of the blend it replaces; in 2019 Daikin pledged free access to its patents for equipment using R-32, an unusual move to speed the switch. The refrigerant story is the environmental history of the whole industry in miniature, and it closes the loop with how air conditioners work.

Quick answers

What refrigerant is in modern air conditioners?

Most current room air conditioners use R-32 or the blend R-410A, with a shift toward R-32 and new low-warming HFOs. Older machines may hold R-22, an ozone-depleting HCFC whose production has been phased out in many countries, on timetables that differ by region.

Why were CFC refrigerants banned?

Freon is a brand name that has been used for CFCs such as CFC-12 and also for HCFCs such as R-22. CFCs release chlorine in the stratosphere that destroys ozone, so the 1987 Montreal Protocol phased them out. HCFCs such as R-22 are being phased out too, on timetables that differ between countries.

Is R-32 bad for the environment?

R-32 does not harm the ozone layer, but it is a greenhouse gas with about a third of the warming power of the R-410A blend it replaces. The Kigali Amendment phases all HFCs down over time.

Sources

The Midgley search and the candle demonstration are from the EPA's refrigerant safety history. The 99 percent phase-out is UNEP's figure; the 0.4 C benefit is UNEP's estimate as compiled in the book's Source Companion. Molina-Rowland is cited from the scholarly record; the DOI is live though the full text is paywalled.

More from this book

Mechanism · From the book The Air Conditioner: Ice, Vapor, Empire

How air conditioners work

Most modern room air conditioners, and the large chillers descended from Carrier's machines, run the same vapour-compression loop: a fluid is squeezed, cooled into liquid, relaxed through a restriction, and boiled back into vapour.

Energy · From the book The Air Conditioner: Ice, Vapor, Empire

Air conditioning's electricity demand, in numbers

About one kilowatt-hour in ten, worldwide, now goes into cooling air.

History · From the book The Air Conditioner: Ice, Vapor, Empire

Who invented air conditioning

Willis Carrier invented modern air conditioning in 1902, but he did not invent it to cool people.