Cover of Soap: Ash, Fat, Foam, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book Soap: Ash, Fat, Foam
Chapters 11 and 21. Read the full book free as a PDF.
Diagram of six steps of cold process soap making: weigh, dissolve lye in water, combine with oils, reach trace, pour into the mould, then cut and cure for three to eight weeks.
The cold process in order, from the Handcrafted Soapmakers Guild. Original IOI diagram.

Three ingredients

The Handcrafted Soapmakers Guild says soap made from scratch needs three ingredients: oil, water and lye. When they are mixed in the right proportions they change chemically into soap. The oil is animal or vegetable, not petroleum-based. Scent, colour and herbs can be added, but they are not part of saponification. The Guild also notes that lye is highly caustic and can burn skin in a few seconds, so soapmakers wear gloves and goggles, including when handling uncured soap.

The right amount of lye depends on the oils chosen. A recipe or a lye calculator works this out, because each oil needs a different amount. The FDA says a properly made soap leaves no lye behind. The reaction behind this is described in how soap is made.

The steps

  1. Make the lye solution. Lye is dissolved in water. The Guild says it usually takes two to three times more water than lye, and the solution heats up as the lye dissolves. It is normally cooled to room temperature before use.
  2. Warm the oils. Oils are heated as needed to melt solid fats or butters, then cooled to roughly 80 to 110 degrees Fahrenheit depending on the recipe.
  3. Combine and mix. Mixing thickens the batter and it heats up. That heat is saponification happening.
  4. Trace. Trace is the point where mixture dribbled from a spoon leaves a brief trace on the surface. Scent, colour, herbs and clays are added now.
  5. Pour. The batter goes into one loaf mould, cut up later, or into individual moulds. It is often insulated to slow the cooling and give saponification more time.
  6. Unmould and cut. When cool and solid, the soap is firm but still soft enough to cut easily.
  7. Cure. The Guild says the soap sits for three to eight weeks while excess water evaporates, depending on how much water was used, plus temperature, humidity and air circulation. It can be used earlier, but it will be softer. The longer the water leaves, the harder the bar.

Cold process versus hot process

In hot process, the lye solution and oils are mixed, then heat is applied to maintain a high temperature, which shortens the time saponification takes. The soap is fully saponified when poured and needs no extra time in the mould. It may still be cured to harden, although less curing is needed. Cold process gives more control over swirls and design in exchange for the longer wait.

Superfat, glycerine and what the bar keeps

Most body soaps are superfatted, with a little extra oil left unreacted. The Wikipedia article says this ensures there is no lye in the soap, makes cake soaps more plastic so they do not crack, and replaces some skin oils lost in washing. A handmade bar also keeps the glycerine the reaction makes. Factory soap usually loses most of it with the spent lye, as shown in the factory route.

Why the wait and the gloves matter

Lye is a real hazard, and the cure is part of the method. Traditional soaps in the old olive oil cities were also left to harden after cutting. The method here is the small-scale version of a process that has been done in cauldrons and kettles for centuries.

Quick answers

What is cold process soap?

A method where lye solution and oils are mixed without added heat, poured into a mould and left to finish saponifying, then cured.

What does trace mean in soap making?

The point where the mixture thickens enough that drizzle from a spoon leaves a brief trace on the surface.

How long does cold process soap take to cure?

Three to eight weeks, depending on water content, temperature, humidity and air circulation.

Is hot process different?

Yes. Outside heat is used to speed saponification so the soap is fully reacted when poured. It may still be cured to harden.

Sources

All steps, temperatures, water ratios and the three to eight week cure are from the Handcrafted Soapmakers Guild. Superfat is from Wikipedia. This article describes the method; it is not a safety manual, and the Guild's lye warnings apply.

More from this book

Process · From the book Soap: Ash, Fat, Foam

How soap is made: from fat and lye to the bar

Soap is the oldest chemical manufacture most people still use every day.

Types · From the book Soap: Ash, Fat, Foam

Types of soap: hard, soft, Castile, Marseille, Aleppo and detergent bars

A bar called soap might be an olive oil block cured for months, a potash paste cooked over a fire, or a synthetic detergent that the regulator says is not soap at all.

History · From the book Soap: Ash, Fat, Foam

The history of soap: from Babylonian clay to the detergent age

Soap goes back about 4,800 years on the written evidence.

Traditional soap · From the book Soap: Ash, Fat, Foam

How African black soap is made: ash, oil and hours over a fire

In traditional African black soap the alkali comes from burnt plant waste, the same ash-and-fat idea found in the oldest written soap evidence.