Cover of Soap: Ash, Fat, Foam, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book Soap: Ash, Fat, Foam
Chapters 4 to 7 and 17. Read the full book free as a PDF.
Several cube-shaped cream-coloured soap bars stamped with the number 600 in a circle, heaped in a woven basket with a few green olive-oil bars among them.
Marseille soap in cubes stamped with their weight, 600 grams, in a street market in Marseille. Photo: Arnaud 25, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

First split: hard and soft

The alkali sets the first division. Sodium hydroxide makes firm soaps. Potassium hydroxide makes softer soaps, often liquid. The Wikipedia soap article adds that lithium soaps are hard and used almost exclusively in greases. Historically, potassium hydroxide was extracted from the ashes of bracken or other plants.

Second split: the fat

The oil changes the hardness, odour and lather, as the NZIC notes for factory soap. Toilet soaps use coconut, olive or palm oils, or tallow, and each has a different fatty acid make-up.

Four old olive oil soaps

Aleppo soap is a hot-process hard soap from Syria. Wikipedia describes it as olive oil and lye with the addition of laurel berry oil, which distinguishes it. It is boiled in a large vat for about three days. Its origin is unknown. Claims that it was used by Cleopatra or Zenobia are unverified, and the same source notes that soap was known to the Romans in the first century and described by Zosimos around 300 AD. In December 2024 UNESCO recognised the craftsmanship of Aleppo Ghar soap as intangible cultural heritage. Laurel oil above 16 percent is considered higher quality.

Wooden shelves in a shop stacked with rectangular pale olive-coloured blocks of Aleppo soap, with bottles of bleach and cleaning liquids on the shelf above.
Blocks of Aleppo soap on a shop shelf, with modern household cleaners above. The uncut block shows the pale outside; the green interior appears when it is cut. Photo: Dosseman, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Nabulsi soap comes from Nablus in Palestine. Its chief ingredients are virgin olive oil, water and an alkaline sodium compound. It is ivory-coloured with almost no scent. It was traditionally made by women for household use, and by the 14th century Nablus had a significant industry.

Marseille soap is a hard vegetable-oil soap made around Marseille, where soapmaking was recorded by the late 14th century. In 1688, Louis XIV introduced the Edict of Colbert limiting the name Savon de Marseille to olive-oil soaps. The law has since been amended to allow other vegetable oils. Today there are two main kinds: the original greenish olive oil bar and a white one made from palm and coconut oil. In 1924 there were 122 soapmakers around Marseille and Salon-de-Provence. By 2023 only four remained.

Castile soap is an olive oil soap in the style of the Castile region of Spain. Wikipedia notes that early Mediterranean soapmakers had no easy access to laurel oil, dropped it, and so created a plain olive oil soap. It is commonly believed that Crusaders brought Aleppo soap back to Europe, although the sources note that this rests on the timing of the earliest European soap.

All four are cousins, and the book treats them as one family tree. The Marseille and Castile soaps are Aleppo soap without the laurel, in the book's words.

Third split: soap or detergent

The FDA says that today there are very few true soaps on the market. Most body cleansers, solid and liquid, are synthetic detergent products. They sell because they make suds easily in water and do not form gummy deposits. Many are marketed as "soap" but are not soap under the regulatory definition.

The FDA definition has three conditions, all required. The product must be composed mainly of the alkali salts of fatty acids. Those salts must be the only material that cleans. And it must be labelled and marketed only for use as soap. A bar marketed to moisturise, perfume or deodorise is a cosmetic, and one marketed to kill germs or treat acne is a drug. Real soap is regulated by the Consumer Product Safety Commission, not the FDA. The American Cleaning Institute dates the shift to detergents to the shortage of fats and oils in the two world wars, when chemists synthesised substitutes.

Handmade and traditional variants

Soap is also grouped by how it is made. Cold process and hot process are covered in cold process soap making. West African black soap is made from plant ash and oils; see how African black soap is made. Factory bars follow the route described here.

Quick answers

What are the main types of soap?

By alkali, sodium (hard) and potassium (soft or liquid). By fat, olive oil soaps such as Castile, Marseille, Aleppo and Nabulsi, or soaps made from coconut, palm and tallow.

What is the difference between Aleppo and Castile soap?

Aleppo soap is an olive oil soap with laurel berry oil added. Castile is a plain olive oil soap in the style of the Castile region of Spain.

Is most soap actually soap?

The FDA says today there are very few true soaps on the market and most body cleansers are synthetic detergent products.

What did the Edict of Colbert do?

In 1688 it limited the name Savon de Marseille to olive-oil soaps. The law has since been amended to allow other vegetable oils.

Sources

The three-part FDA definition and the statement that few true soaps remain are from the FDA FAQ. The olive oil soap histories are from the Wikipedia pages listed, which cite regional historians; they are secondary and several claims there are labelled as disputed, which this article keeps. The Aleppo photo caption describes a shop shelf, not an authentic-origin claim.

More from this book

History · From the book Soap: Ash, Fat, Foam

The history of soap: from Babylonian clay to the detergent age

Soap goes back about 4,800 years on the written evidence.

Process · From the book Soap: Ash, Fat, Foam

How soap is made: from fat and lye to the bar

Soap is the oldest chemical manufacture most people still use every day.

Technique · From the book Soap: Ash, Fat, Foam

Cold process soap making: how it works, what trace means and why you cure

Cold process is the method most handmade soap uses.

Traditional soap · From the book Soap: Ash, Fat, Foam

How African black soap is made: ash, oil and hours over a fire

In traditional African black soap the alkali comes from burnt plant waste, the same ash-and-fat idea found in the oldest written soap evidence.