Cover of Coal: Seam, Fire, Grid, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book Coal: Seam, Fire, Grid
Chapters 11, 12 and 13. Read the full book free as a PDF.

The fork in the road is depth. The U.S. Energy Information Administration draws the line at about 200 feet: above it, surface mining usually wins; below it, the seam belongs to the underground miners. Surface mining is cheaper and safer per tonne, which is why roughly two-thirds of American coal comes out of pits rather than shafts.

Surface mining: unmaking a landscape to get at a seam

A surface mine works like archaeology in reverse with much larger tools. Bulldozers and scrapers strip the soil, drills and explosives loosen the rock above the seam, the overburden, and then the giants arrive. Draglines walk across the pit swinging buckets the size of houses. Bucket-wheel excavators, the largest land machines ever built, shave the benches with a wheel of scoops the height of an apartment block. The coal itself is then small work: loaders fill trucks that climb the terraced ramps to the preparation plant.

A panoramic view across a vast terraced open-pit mine with a giant bucket-wheel excavator working a bench in the distance.
A bucket-wheel excavator at the Garzweiler surface mine in Germany, one of the largest land machines ever built, stripping lignite from terraced benches. Photo: Arne Museler, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Mountaintop removal is the most aggressive form: ridges in Appalachia are literally levelled to reach the thin seams inside, with the spoil pushed into adjacent valleys. When the coal is gone, the pit is regraded and replanted, though a rebuilt hill is not the hill that was there.

Underground mining: the deep seam economy

Below 200 feet the logic inverts. Moving that much rock is impossible, so the miners go to the coal instead, riding cages down shafts and small trains through tunnels that can run for miles. Two methods dominate.

Room-and-pillar is the older: miners cut a grid of rooms into the seam and leave pillars of coal standing to hold up the roof. It is simple and flexible, but it abandons a large share of the seam underground as pillars, sometimes more than half. The continuous miner, a machine that claws coal off the face with a rotating drum, made this method the workhorse of American underground mining.

Longwall mining is the modern answer to the pillar problem. A shearer, a machine with two spinning cutting drums, travels back and forth across a face that may be 300 metres wide, slicing coal onto an armoured conveyor. Hydraulic roof supports hold up the roof only where the crew is working; behind them, the roof is allowed to collapse in a controlled way. Nothing is left as pillars, so recovery is high, and the system is heavily automated.

A large rotating cutting drum studded with picks on a longwall shearer machine inside a low mine gallery.
A longwall shearer at the Guido mine, Zabrze, Poland. The spinning drum cuts coal off the face as the machine travels back and forth along the seam. Photo: Rudolf H. Boettcher, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

From run-of-mine to cargo

The machines have changed the workforce beyond recognition. By the EIA's reckoning, American miners today produce about three times more coal in an hour than they did in 1978, not because they work harder but because the equipment does the working. A modern longwall face is run by a handful of operators monitoring sensors and hydraulics, a world away from the pick-and-shovel pit of the history books, though the geology underneath is the same.

What comes out of the ground is not yet a product. Run-of-mine coal is mixed with rock, and almost all of it passes through a preparation plant, where screens, jigs and dense-medium baths separate coal from stone using gravity. Washing cuts ash and sulphur, raises the heat value per tonne, and means the railway ships fuel rather than dirt. The leftover refuse, along with the fine slurry, becomes the mine's own waste problem, historically its most dangerous one.

Only then does the coal start the journey described in the rest of the industry: unit trains a hundred wagons long, port stockyards, colliers across oceans, and finally the bunkers of a power station, where the stone that burns becomes fire and then the grid.

Quick answers

What are the two main types of coal mining?

Surface mining, which strips soil and rock above shallow seams, and underground (deep) mining, which reaches deeper seams through shafts and tunnels. The dividing line is roughly 200 feet of cover, per the U.S. EIA.

What is longwall mining?

Longwall mining shears coal off a wide face with a machine running between hydraulic roof supports, letting the roof collapse behind it. It recovers far more of the seam than room-and-pillar mining, which must leave coal pillars standing.

Why is coal washed after mining?

Washing in a preparation plant removes rock and impurities, cutting ash and sulphur and raising heating value. It means customers pay to ship coal, not stone.

Sources

The 200-foot rule of thumb and the surface share of U.S. production are from the U.S. Energy Information Administration. Method details follow Chapters 11-13 of the book.

More from this book

Materials · From the book Coal: Seam, Fire, Grid

Types of coal: the ranks from lignite to anthracite

Not all coal is equal.

History · From the book Coal: Seam, Fire, Grid

The history of coal mining, from sea coal to steam

Coal was a curiosity for most of human history, a black stone that burned.

Process · From the book Coal: Seam, Fire, Grid

How a coal power station works

A coal power station is a kettle on an industrial scale: grind the coal, burn the powder, boil water into steam, spin a turbine, catch the steam and start again.