Cover of Sodium Benzoate, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book Sodium Benzoate
Chapters 1 to 3 and 26 to 28. Read the full book free as a PDF.
A small heap of dark reddish-brown, glassy lumps of benzoin resin on a white background.
Benzoin resin (Sumatra benzoin, from Styrax benzoin), the source of benzoic acid before the toluene route. Photo: Maša Sinreih and Valentina Vivod, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

The resin

Benzoic acid was discovered in the sixteenth century. Wikipedia reports that dry distillation of gum benzoin was first described by Nostradamus in 1556, then by Alexius Pedemontanus in 1560 and Blaise de Vigenere in 1596. Gum benzoin is the resin of Styrax benzoin trees, and benzoic acid is its principal component. The acid and the resin are still found in tincture of benzoin and Friar's balsam, which have a long history as topical antiseptics and inhalant decongestants. Justus von Liebig and Friedrich Wohler later determined the composition of benzoic acid.

Watercolour botanical plate of Styrax benzoin showing a green leafy twig with small white flowers and round grey-green fruit, in an open album page.
Styrax benzoin, watercolour, about 1893, by George De Alwis (Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History botany collection record). Photo: George De Alwis, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The first industrial route, and why it was dropped for food

The first industrial process reacted benzotrichloride with calcium hydroxide in water, with iron as catalyst, then converted the calcium benzoate to benzoic acid with hydrochloric acid. The product contained significant amounts of chlorinated benzoic acid derivatives. For that reason, Wikipedia says, benzoic acid for human consumption was obtained by dry distillation of gum benzoin for a time.

The modern route

Diagram of the industrial route to sodium benzoate: toluene is oxidised with air over a cobalt or manganese catalyst to benzoic acid, which is neutralised with sodium hydroxide to give sodium benzoate.
The modern route to sodium benzoate. Original IOI diagram, from Wikipedia and the US eCFR.

Benzoic acid is now produced commercially by partial oxidation of toluene with oxygen. The process is catalysed by cobalt or manganese naphthenates, uses abundant materials and proceeds in high yield, according to Wikipedia. The final step is chemical bookkeeping. Sodium benzoate is commonly produced by neutralising benzoic acid with sodium hydroxide, and the US eCFR lists sodium bicarbonate and sodium carbonate as the other accepted neutralising agents. The eCFR requires the food ingredient to meet the Food Chemicals Codex specification.

What the oxidation actually involves

A European patent on benzoic acid manufacture (EP0300921) summarises the earlier art. The main procedure, it says, is liquid-phase oxidation of toluene with air or oxygen in the presence of metal catalysts. Suitable catalysts are salts of metals with variable valency such as chromium, cobalt, manganese, iron, copper, nickel and vanadium. One cited example oxidises toluene with a soluble cobalt or manganese salt, acetic acid and sodium bromide at 20 atmospheres and 125 to 130 degrees Celsius for 220 minutes. The patent also records the cost of the promoter: bromide ion speeds the reaction but corrodes the apparatus and forces the use of corrosion-resistant equipment. The patent's own invention concerns a high-purity route using a phase-transfer catalyst. These are conditions from patent background text, and a given plant will differ.

Forms sold

Sodium benzoate is sold in more than one physical form. Eastman, one manufacturer, lists a granular food-grade product and two powders, one engineered for extremely low moisture. The pH of a 1 percent solution is reported as 6.5 to 8.0 for both forms, and all dissolve readily in water. Wikipedia gives the solubility in water as about 62.7 grams per 100 mL at 0 degrees Celsius.

Why it is not a plant product anymore

Natural benzoate is a minor material today. The FDA's note on benzene observes that benzoate salts are also naturally present in some fruits and juices such as cranberries, but the sodium benzoate in food is made chemically. The eCFR states that the salt itself is not found to occur naturally. What it does in food is in sodium benzoate as a preservative, and other uses are in sodium benzoate uses.

Quick answers

How is sodium benzoate made?

Toluene is oxidised with oxygen over a cobalt or manganese catalyst to give benzoic acid, which is neutralised with sodium hydroxide, carbonate or bicarbonate.

Where does benzoic acid come from naturally?

Gum benzoin, the resin of Styrax benzoin, is its principal natural source. It is also found in berries and cranberries.

Who discovered benzoic acid?

Its dry distillation from gum benzoin was first described by Nostradamus in 1556, according to Wikipedia.

Is sodium benzoate natural?

The US eCFR says the salt is not found to occur naturally. Benzoic acid occurs naturally in plants.

Sources

The eCFR text is the US legal description of the salt. Eastman data are one manufacturer's typical values.

More from this book

Preservative · From the book Sodium Benzoate

Sodium benzoate as a preservative: how it works and where it is used

Sodium benzoate does not kill spoilage so much as make it hard for yeasts and moulds to keep growing.

E-number · From the book Sodium Benzoate

What is E211? Benzoate E-numbers E210 to E213 explained

E211 is sodium benzoate.

Safety · From the book Sodium Benzoate

Is sodium benzoate safe? What FDA, EFSA and the benzene and hyperactivity studies found

The honest answer is that regulators call it low in toxicity at normal use, and that there are two specific questions worth knowing about: benzene in some drinks, and a children's behaviour study that regulators did not treat as proof.

Uses · From the book Sodium Benzoate

Sodium benzoate uses: food, medicine, cosmetics and fireworks

Most people meet sodium benzoate on a food label.