Safety · Materials · Chemicals
Is sodium benzoate safe? What FDA, EFSA and the benzene and hyperactivity studies found
The honest answer is that regulators call it low in toxicity at normal use, and that there are two specific questions worth knowing about: benzene in some drinks, and a children's behaviour study that regulators did not treat as proof.
From the book Sodium BenzoateChapters 21, 23, 24 and 25. Read the full book free as a PDF.
What regulators say
In the United States, sodium benzoate is GRAS, generally recognised as safe, under 21 CFR 184.1733. In Europe, EFSA re-evaluated benzoic acid and its sodium, potassium and calcium salts (E 210 to E 213) in 2016. It found the toxicity low in short-term and sub-chronic studies, no concern about genotoxicity, and no indication of carcinogenic potential. From a four-generation rat study with a no-observed-adverse-effect level of 500 mg benzoic acid per kg of body weight per day, the highest dose tested, EFSA derived an acceptable daily intake of 5 mg/kg bw per day, expressed as benzoic acid, using an uncertainty factor of 100.
EFSA also found that the group ADI could be exceeded. Under a brand-loyal scenario that counted only direct additions, the ADI was exceeded especially for toddlers and children who regularly drink flavoured drinks. Counting carry-over from other sources could raise intake two to three fold for high-level consumers, and the main contributing categories were unprocessed fruits and vegetables and flavoured drinks. This is an exposure estimate, not a finding of harm, and it is the reason the question is not closed for children.
Benzene in soft drinks
The FDA's Q&A explains that benzene can form at very low levels, parts per billion, in beverages that contain both benzoate salts and ascorbic acid (vitamin C) or erythorbic acid. Heat and light can stimulate the formation. The FDA first learned of it in 1990, when industry reported it. In November 2005 it received new reports and began a survey of almost 200 samples, from 2005 through May 2007. A small number of products had more than 5 ppb, which is the EPA's maximum contaminant level for benzene in drinking water. Manufacturers reformulated, and the FDA's tests of reformulated products found less than 1.5 ppb. The FDA concluded that the levels found do not pose a safety concern. Benzene is a carcinogen at high workplace exposure, which is why the 5 ppb line mattered.
The Southampton study
In 2007 researchers at the University of Southampton, funded by the UK Food Standards Agency, reported in The Lancet a trial with 153 three-year-olds and 144 children aged 8 and 9. After a six-week additive-free diet, the children received daily drinks that held one of two mixtures of artificial colours and sodium benzoate, or just fruit juice. The drinks looked and tasted the same. In some cases the children were significantly more hyperactive on the test mixtures. The lead author said parents should not think removing the additives would prevent all hyperactive disorders.
EFSA assessed the study in 2008. It concluded the study gave limited evidence that the mixtures had a small effect on the activity and attention of some children, but that the effects were not consistent across the two age groups and two mixtures, and the clinical significance was unknown. Because mixtures and not single additives were tested, it could not say which additive was responsible. It said the findings could not be used as a basis for changing the ADI for the colours or sodium benzoate.
What to take from this
Two points hold up. At the doses regulators allow, benzoate has low toxicity in the studies reviewed. And the specific cases, benzoate with vitamin C in a warm, bright-lit drink, and heavy drink intake in small children, are the ones where the evidence leaves some real uncertainty. That is a narrower statement than "safe" or "dangerous". How the preservative works is in sodium benzoate as a preservative, and the label code is in what E211 means.
Quick answers
Is sodium benzoate safe to eat?
US regulators class it GRAS and EFSA found low toxicity and an ADI of 5 mg/kg bw per day as benzoic acid. EFSA also estimated children who drink a lot of flavoured drinks could exceed it.
Does sodium benzoate cause cancer?
EFSA's 2016 review found no indication of carcinogenic potential. Benzene, a carcinogen, can form at ppb levels when benzoate meets vitamin C in some drinks.
Does sodium benzoate cause hyperactivity?
A 2007 Southampton study of colour-plus-benzoate mixtures found some increased hyperactivity. EFSA judged the evidence limited and inconsistent and did not change the ADI.
How was the benzene problem handled?
Manufacturers reformulated. The FDA found reformulated products below 1.5 ppb, under the 5 ppb EPA drinking water limit.
Sources
- 21 CFR 184.1733, Sodium benzoate (US eCFR, via Cornell LII)
- EFSA ANS Panel, re-evaluation of benzoic acid (E 210), sodium benzoate (E 211), potassium benzoate (E 212) and calcium benzoate (E 213) (2016), summary as reported by Ingredients Network, 13 April 2016
- US FDA, "Questions and Answers on the Occurrence of Benzene in Soft Drinks and Other Beverages"
- University of Southampton, "Major study indicates a link between hyperactivity in children and certain food additives" (6 Sept 2007)
- EFSA, "EFSA evaluates Southampton study on food additives and child behaviour" (14 March 2008)
