Cover of The Movie: Shadow, Celluloid, Stream, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book The Movie: Shadow, Celluloid, Stream
Chapters 14 and 15. Read the full book free as a PDF.

Why earlier attempts failed

The Library of Congress essay on the film, by Ron Hutchinson of the Vitaphone Project, says dozens of sound systems were tried from 1896 and failed. Most tied a record to a separate projector. The essay names three weaknesses: no reliable synchronisation, no way to fill a theatre with sound from a horn phonograph, and poor recording. Edison's Kinetophone failed partly, the essay says, because rats chewed the pulleys connecting the phonograph to the projector. The studios saw no reason to risk a profitable business.

Vitaphone

That changed when Sam Warner saw Bell Labs' new sound film system in 1925. The essay explains the design: one motor drove both the projector and the turntable holding a 16-inch disc carrying the soundtrack, electrical recording replaced the horn, and new loudspeakers could fill a theatre. Warner Bros. acquired the system in June 1925, according to a biography of the Bell Labs engineer George Groves. Disc speed was set at 33 and a third revolutions a minute, and the film ran at 24 frames per second.

Warner's first plan was not talking. Sam Warner saw Vitaphone as a way of giving small theatres a full orchestra for silent pictures. Don Juan in 1926 had recorded music and effects and no dialogue. The audience reaction to the short talking and singing films shown before it, the essay says, changed the plan.

The Jazz Singer

Warners signed Al Jolson, whose short in 1926 had electrified an audience. Production began in early summer 1927, with Jolson's singing and talking sequences shot over nine days from 17 August. The sound was recorded on discs while three cameras ran together. The essay is careful about myths. Jolson was not an accidental talker: his 1926 contract specified that he would sing and speak. But the famous lines to his screen mother, about moving to the Bronx, were not in the script and he probably made them up.

The film premiered in two theatres on 6 October 1927. It was largely silent, with music and sound effects covering most of it, and had about two minutes of actual dialogue. Projectionists at first handled 25 separate disks, later reduced to ten. Reviews were mixed. It cost $422,000 and by 1931 had earned $2 million. By March 1928 it was in 235 theatres. The first all-talking feature, The Lights of New York, came in 1928 and cost $23,000 to make, but earned over a million dollars. By the end of 1929, the essay says, the silent picture was dead.

Timeline: Warner Bros. acquires the system in June 1925, Don Juan in 1926, The Jazz Singer on 6 October 1927, 235 theatres in March 1928, silents gone by the end of 1929.
Sound arrives. Original IOI diagram.

Why sound on film won

Warner's discs were the way in, but not the way to stay. The Electronics Guide history explains that the rival approach photographed the sound: a microphone signal changed a light source, which exposed a stripe along the film, and in the projector a lamp read the stripe. Fox bought sound-on-film patents on 23 July 1926 and built Movietone, first used in newsreels. Because picture and sound sat on the same strip, nothing could go out of step. Disc systems relied on a separate record staying in step with the film.

Conversion was uneven. In the United States only about half of the theatres had been wired for sound by 1930, so studios issued silent and sound versions of the same film. More than half of French theatres still showed silent pictures in late 1932, and in the Soviet Union in May 1933 fewer than one projector in a hundred could play sound, according to the same history. The silent era ended at different times in different countries.

Sound reshaped the studios as much as the films. The Library of Congress says the success funded Warners' purchase of hundreds of theatres and the First National studio, and that its stock rose from $21 to $132. Warner was one of the eight defendants in the federal antitrust case that followed. See the Paramount decrees.

Quick answers

Was The Jazz Singer the first talking movie?

No. The Library of Congress essay says it was not the first or even the thousandth talking picture. It was the first successful synchronised feature with talking. It had about two minutes of dialogue.

When did The Jazz Singer premiere?

On 6 October 1927, in two theatres. By March 1928 it was in 235 theatres.

What was Vitaphone?

A sound-on-disc system developed by Western Electric and Bell Labs and used by Warner Bros. A 16-inch disc was synchronised with the projector by one motor.

Sources

The history of failed sound systems, Vitaphone's design, the Jazz Singer production, the 6 October 1927 premiere, the two minutes of dialogue, 25 and ten disks, 235 theatres in March 1928, costs and earnings, the Lights of New York and the stock rise are from the Library of Congress essay by Ron Hutchinson. The June 1925 date comes from the George Groves biography page. The 33 and a third rpm disc speed and the 24 frames per second rate are consistent with Groves, Electronics Guide and other technical histories. Movietone, the 23 July 1926 Fox purchase and the uneven conversion dates are from the Electronics Guide. The book's own dates agree on 6 October 1927 and Vitaphone's 16-inch discs.

More from this book

History · From the book The Movie: Shadow, Celluloid, Stream

The first paid movie show: Lumière, Paris, 28 December 1895

On 28 December 1895 about thirty people paid one franc each to sit in the basement of a Paris café and watch ten short films.

Materials · From the book The Movie: Shadow, Celluloid, Stream

Why old movies burned: nitrate film and the lost silent films

For decades the movie industry recorded its pictures on a material that could set itself alight.

Business · From the book The Movie: Shadow, Celluloid, Stream

The Paramount decrees of 1948: how an antitrust case split Hollywood

For seventy years a federal court order decided who could own a cinema.

Business · From the book The Movie: Shadow, Celluloid, Stream

Streaming vs theatres: what the 2020 box office collapse showed

In 2020 the world's cinemas shut and global box office fell to $12.2 billion, from $42.5 billion a year earlier.