Business · Communication Services · Entertainment
The Paramount decrees of 1948: how an antitrust case split Hollywood
For seventy years a federal court order decided who could own a cinema. The Paramount decrees, from a case the Supreme Court decided on 3 May 1948, split the studios from the theatres and reshaped what Americans saw.
From the book The Movie: Shadow, Celluloid, StreamChapters 21 to 23. Read the full book free as a PDF.
The case
In 1938 the US Department of Justice sued eight film companies: Paramount, Twentieth Century-Fox, Loew's (now MGM), RKO, Warner Brothers, Columbia, Universal and United Artists. The Justice Department says the district court found they had conspired to fix prices and to monopolise both film distribution and the theatre market. The Supreme Court upheld those findings in United States v. Paramount Pictures, 334 U.S. 131, in 1948.
The studios did not only make films. Five of the eight owned theatres, which meant they could decide what played in their own houses and use their power to press independent cinemas. The case is named after one defendant, but it governed all of them.
What the decrees required
Each defendant then signed a consent decree with the Department. The Department says the decrees did two things. First, they separated distribution from exhibition. The five defendants that owned theatres had to give up either their distribution business or their cinemas, and could not do both without court approval. Second, they banned certain practices: block booking, which bundled several films into one licence; circuit dealing, a single licence covering every theatre in a chain; resale price maintenance, which set minimum ticket prices; and overbroad clearances, exclusive licences for a geographic area.
The ban on block booking mattered most for what reached the screen. Under block booking an exhibitor had to take a studio's weaker films to get its strong ones. Under the decrees, films had to be offered theatre by theatre and film by film.
What changed afterward
The Justice Department says the decrees altered the structure of the industry. None of the Paramount defendants owns a significant number of theatres today. Single-screen first-run palaces gave way to multiplexes. What the primary record shows is narrow: the studios were forced to separate making and distributing films from showing them, and the banned practices changed how theatres could license films.
Why the decrees ended
In 2019 the Department moved to end the decrees, arguing that the industry had changed. Its press release said, as quoted by JURIST, that technology "has created many different distribution and viewing platforms that did not exist when the decrees where entered into", and listed cable, broadcast television, DVDs and streaming. On 7 August 2020 Judge Analisa Torres of the Southern District of New York granted the motion, finding that termination was in the public interest and that it was unlikely the studios would collude again to limit distribution to a select group of theatres.
The order, signed on 7 August 2020, included a two-year sunset for the decree provisions on both block booking and circuit dealing. The court said this would give theatres a transition period to adjust their business models to any proposals to change the film-by-film, theatre-by-theatre licensing system.
The question the decrees leave open
The decrees ended when exhibition no longer meant theatres alone. The book's argument, and one worth testing against the record, is that the streamers now own production, distribution and the place of viewing, which the decrees would once have prohibited. That is a claim about market structure, not a statement of law. The decrees were never written for the internet, and no court has applied them to it. See how streaming and the 2020 closures broke the theatrical window. For the money that built the studios' theatre chains in the first place, see how sound paid for Warners' theatre purchases.
Quick answers
What were the Paramount decrees?
Consent decrees signed after the 1948 Supreme Court case United States v. Paramount Pictures. They forced studios that owned theatres to separate distribution from exhibition and banned block booking and other practices.
What is block booking?
Bundling several films into one theatre licence, so an exhibitor must take weaker films to get strong ones. The decrees banned it.
When did the Paramount decrees end?
A federal judge granted the Department of Justice's request to terminate them in August 2020, with a two-year sunset on its block-booking and circuit-dealing provisions.
Sources
- US Department of Justice, Antitrust Division: The Paramount Decrees
- US Department of Justice, press release: Department of Justice files motion to terminate the Paramount Consent Decrees
- JURIST, Federal judge grants DOJ bid to scrap antitrust rules limiting how movies are distributed to theaters (8 August 2020)
- U.S. District Court order terminating the Paramount Consent Decrees, signed 7 August 2020 (Justice Department Antitrust Division)
