Materials · Communication Services · Entertainment
Why old movies burned: nitrate film and the lost silent films
For decades the movie industry recorded its pictures on a material that could set itself alight. The result is not only fires. It is a hole in film history: about 70 percent of American silent feature films made from 1912 to 1929 are gone.
From the book The Movie: Shadow, Celluloid, StreamChapter 7. Read the full book free as a PDF.
What nitrate is, and why studios used it
The base of early film was cellulose nitrate, a transparent, light and flexible plastic. The US National Park Service says it was most common between about 1910 and 1950 and that, in the twentieth century, photographers and filmmakers used it more than any other film support. It was the standard film base for most of that period, even though its dangers were known.
How it burns
The Library of Congress describes nitrate base film as highly flammable. It can self-ignite at ambient temperatures around 100 degrees Fahrenheit, and once alight it cannot be extinguished. The National Park Service adds that deteriorated nitrate can burn under water, and that the gases from a nitrate fire are lethal. A University of South Carolina Libraries paper explains why water does not help: the material carries enough oxygen in its own chemistry to keep burning without outside air.
Nitrate also fails slowly without any fire. As it decays it gives off nitric oxide and nitrogen dioxide, acidic gases that irritate the lungs and damage paper, metal and other film nearby. The Library of Congress describes the emulsion softening, blistering and bubbling, and finally turning into a handful of fine red powder. A vault of old reels was therefore both a fire risk and a slow chemical problem.
The Fox vault fire of 1937
On 9 July 1937 a fire destroyed vaults of the Fox film company. The San Francisco Silent Film Festival, which collects archive histories, records 42 vaults and 57 truckloads of burnt nitrate and says the majority of silent films produced by Fox went up. The fire is an example of what archivists feared, not the only one.
Fire was only part of the loss
Fire was not the main reason silents disappeared. The Library of Congress study found that neglect and decay did more damage, and that studios had little financial reason to keep old films. Vaults cost money. Silent pictures became commercially obsolete almost overnight when sound arrived. Some films were thrown away to save storage costs and remove the fire risk, and the silver in the emulsion could be recovered and sold. Prints were often sold outright to exhibitors, who ran them until they stopped earning and then discarded them.
The numbers come from a 2013 survey by the historian-archivist David Pierce for the National Film Preservation Board. Of 10,919 American silent feature films made from 1912 to 1929 in the study, about 70 percent no longer exist in any form that was surveyed, and only 14 percent, about 1,575 titles, survive in their original format. The Library of Congress describes the report as a road map to finding silent films once thought gone.
Where the safety of film changed
The industry did not give up nitrate for 35 mm production quickly. The Library of Congress notes that acetate "safety" film is not flammable like nitrate, but it is unstable in its own way: it degrades by a self-feeding chemical process that makes it brittle and shrinks it until the image is lost. So moving to safety film did not end the storage problem. It changed it.
The advice that archives follow today is plain. Keep nitrate cool and below 70 degrees Fahrenheit, with relative humidity between 30 and 40 percent. Keep it away from heat in ventilated containers, apart from other collections. Above all, copy it onto stable stock before it decays further. The Park Service says the main method of preserving nitrate is to duplicate it onto safety film before it reaches the late stage of deterioration.
The same fear of fire shaped the cinema itself. A related story, the Bazar de la Charité fire in Paris on 4 May 1897 that killed 126 people, is often told as a film-fire story, but French records say it began when a match was struck in a room filled with ether vapour from the projector's lamp. For the people who first showed those films, read what was on the programme at the first paid show.
Quick answers
Why did old movies burn so easily?
Early film used a cellulose nitrate base. The Library of Congress says it can self-ignite at ambient temperatures around 100 degrees Fahrenheit and cannot be extinguished once alight. It carries its own oxygen, so it can burn even under water.
How many silent films are lost?
The Library of Congress study published in 2013 found that about 70 percent of American silent feature films made from 1912 to 1929 are lost. Only 14 percent, about 1,575 of 10,919 titles, survive in their original format.
Was nitrate film the main reason silent films were lost?
No. The Library of Congress says neglect and decay were the main causes. Studios saw old films as having little value, and some destroyed prints to save storage costs and recover silver.
Sources
- Library of Congress, Preservation: Care, handling and storage of motion picture film
- US National Park Service, Conserve O Gram 14/8: Caring for cellulose nitrate film
- University of South Carolina Libraries, faculty publication on nitrate film hazards
- San Francisco Silent Film Festival, Amazing Tales from the Archives 2008 (Fox vault fire, 9 July 1937)
- Library of Congress, Study finds 70 percent of American silent feature films are lost (4 December 2013)
- RetroNews (BnF), L'incendie du Bazar de la Charité en 1897
