Raw material · Consumer Staples · Food Products
Beet sugar vs cane sugar: how Europe learned to make sugar at home
Sugar from beet and sugar from cane are the same molecule. The difference is the plant, the climate it grows in and the politics that made Europe want its own.
From the book Sugar: Plant, Crystal, EmpireParts III and V. Read the full book free as a PDF.

The same sugar
The World Sugar Research Organisation says sugar is produced naturally in both sugar beet and sugar cane, and that both are harvested, washed, the juice extracted, boiled, refined to remove impurities and crystallised. Chemically the product is sucrose in either case.
Two plants, two climates
Cane is a tropical grass. Beet is a root crop that grows in temperate fields, such as the one in the photograph in Nottinghamshire. WSRO reports that harvested sugar beet root contains 12 to 20 percent sugar, with about 75 percent water and 5 percent pulp, so it must be processed to extract the sugar. After washing, beets are sliced into thin strips called cossettes, mixed with hot water to extract the sugar, and the syrup is filtered, heated and crystallised. The crystals are removed, washed, dried and cooled. The cane route is in how sugar is made from sugarcane.
What the standard says
A 2023 letter from United Sugar Producers and Refiners, a US company that sells both, explains it in industry terms. Both beet and cane sugar meet the Codex Alimentarius standard for white refined sugar, which sets purity at no less than 99.7 percent sucrose. The company says its white sugar routinely measures 99.9 percent, and that the empirical formula, C12H22O11, is the same from either plant. The small remainder is trace non-sugar material that reflects the difference between a grass and a root.
It also admits one difference. Beet sugar has an initial odour profile slightly stronger than cane sugar, which quickly volatilises when exposed to air, handling and water. The company says this does not carry into the taste or odour of finished foods. Treat that as a producer's statement, not an independent test. Either way, a US beet processor and a Florida cane processor sell sugar under the same standard, and much beet sugar is also packed for home bakers.
A German discovery
Wikipedia's history says sugar was a luxury in Europe until the early nineteenth century, when beet sugar in Prussia, and later France under Napoleon, made it widely available. In 1747 Andreas Sigismund Marggraf announced the discovery of sugar in beets and devised a method using alcohol to extract it. His student Franz Karl Achard devised an economical industrial extraction method. The article says their work was the starting point for the sugar industry in Europe, and for the modern industry, because sugar stopped being a product made almost only in warm climates.
Napoleon and the blockade
Cut off from Caribbean imports by a British blockade, and not wanting to fund British merchants, Napoleon ordered 32,000 hectares planted with beetroot in March 1811 and banned sugar imports from 1 January 1813. A beet sugar industry emerged, especially after Jean-Baptiste Queruel industrialised the operation of Benjamin Delessert.
What changed for cane
The article notes that the abolition of slavery in the 1800s led to a partial shift of cane production away from the Americas toward East Asia. The social history behind cane's rise is in sugar and slavery, and how sugar spread in the first place is in the origin and history of sugar.
Does it matter which you buy?
The two white sugars are chemically the same. The one difference with a clear source is the one covered in brown sugar versus white sugar: the molasses for brown sugar comes from cane, not beet, according to the IFIC.
Quick answers
Is beet sugar the same as cane sugar?
Both are sucrose. They come from different plants, a root crop and a tropical grass.
Who discovered sugar in beets?
Andreas Sigismund Marggraf announced it in 1747. His student Franz Karl Achard developed an economical industrial method.
Why did Napoleon promote beet sugar?
A British blockade cut off Caribbean imports. In March 1811 he ordered 32,000 hectares of beet planted, and from 1 January 1813 he banned sugar imports.
How much sugar is in a sugar beet?
Harvested beet root contains 12 to 20 percent sugar, with about 75 percent water and 5 percent pulp, according to WSRO.
