Cover of Sugar: Plant, Crystal, Empire, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book Sugar: Plant, Crystal, Empire
Part XI: Sugar and society. Read the full book free as a PDF.
Pencil and wash drawing of a gang of enslaved Africans with long-handled hoes working in a cane field, with a white overseer at the right and a windmill and buildings on a hill behind.
"African Slaves working in a sugar plantation in Barbados, 1807-1808", drawn by Ralph Stennett for John Augustine Waller. A work gang with long-handled hoes and a white overseer, and a sugar works in the background. Photo: John Augustine Waller (writer) and Ralph Stennett (draughtsman), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Why sugar needed so much labour

The Wikipedia history of sugar says sugar is complicated and time-consuming to grow and process, and that it demanded far more labour, capital and expertise than tobacco or cotton. That demand led to slavery. The labour force at first included European indentured servants and local Native American and African enslaved people; the trade in enslaved Africans grew. The image shows a work gang of enslaved Africans with hoes and a white overseer in Barbados in 1807 to 1808.

Barbados: where the pattern was set

King's College London's Caribbean exhibition, drawing on Richard Ligon's 1657 history, gives a clear case. Barbados was settled by the English in 1627 and was the first English West Indian colony to grow sugar commercially. Tobacco was the early cash crop. In the 1640s its price collapsed, and some planters switched to sugar. They learned the techniques from the Dutch in Brazil. Ligon arrived in 1647 and found the first sugar barely saleable. By the time he left, three years later, it was much better.

Then the economics changed the island. Holdings were small and labour came from indentured servants plus a small number of African and Indian slaves. But sugar on small plots did not pay, so land consolidated into larger plantations, and indentured labour could not meet the need for workers. The exhibition says there were an estimated 50 enslaved Africans on Barbados in 1629 and more than 50,000 by 1666.

The Barbados government's UNESCO tentative-list nomination names the same turn. From the 1640s, it says, European demand for sugar created a socioeconomic revolution, and the intense, unforgiving agro-industrial process condemned the enslaved Africans who raised the crop to lifelong abuse. It quotes the historian B. W. Higman's summary of the Sugar Revolution as a shift from diversified farming to monoculture, from small farms to large plantations, from free to slave labour, from sparse to dense settlement and from white to black populations. It adds that the pattern was exported across the Caribbean, and to Charles Towne, now Charleston, South Carolina, which Barbadian settlers founded, and to Suriname.

The scale of the trade

SlaveVoyages, the research database of the trans-Atlantic trade, estimates that about 12.5 million people were embarked from Africa between 1501 and 1866. Its table by half-century shows the shape: about 64,000 in 1501 to 1550, 213,000 in 1551 to 1600, 668,000 in 1601 to 1650 and 1.2 million in 1651 to 1700. The totals then rose to 2.6 million in 1701 to 1750 and 3.9 million in 1751 to 1800, before falling to 3.6 million in 1801 to 1850 and about 226,000 for the last years to 1866. The largest source region in the table is West Central Africa and St. Helena, with about 5.7 million. These are estimates of those embarked. They are not an estimate of how many worked on sugar, and this article does not give a share.

How dependent the colonies were

The Wikipedia article reports that the Caribbean colonies produced up to 90 percent of the sugar western Europeans consumed, and that sugar provided 93 percent of Barbados's exports and 97 percent of the British Leeward Islands'. The French colony of Saint-Domingue became the world's largest producer by 1750. After the abolition of slavery in the colony and its independence in 1804, production fell sharply. Sugar was also grown by enslaved Black labourers in the United States, in Louisiana, where the first commercial cane crop was produced in 1795.

After abolition: indentured labour

When slavery ended, sugar regions often turned to indentured labour. The article quotes a description of workers shipped across the world and held in conditions of near slavery for up to ten years. Between 1838 and 1917 around 450,000 indentured labourers went from India to the British West Indies (Museum of London Docklands), and others went to Natal, Mauritius and Fiji. The abolition of slavery in the 1800s also led to a partial shift of sugar production back toward East Asia, according to the same source.

Where to read next

For the plant and the crystal, see the origin and history of sugar. For the modern factory, see how sugar is made.

Quick answers

Why was slavery linked to sugar?

Sugar needed far more labour, capital and expertise than tobacco or cotton, and planters turned to enslaved Africans after other labour sources fell short.

How many people were enslaved and shipped across the Atlantic?

SlaveVoyages estimates about 12.5 million people were embarked from Africa between 1501 and 1866.

What happened after slavery ended?

Sugar regions often used indentured labour. Around 450,000 indentured labourers went from India to the British West Indies between 1838 and 1917, according to the Museum of London Docklands.

Which colony led sugar production in the 18th century?

The French colony of Saint-Domingue, by 1750.

Sources

The Barbados account is from an institutional exhibition (King's College London, quoting Ligon, a 1650 eyewitness) and a UNESCO tentative-list nomination written by the Barbados government, which quotes Higman; the nomination argues for heritage status, so read its framing as that. Embarkation figures are SlaveVoyages estimates for 1501-1866, revised periodically. Colony export shares are an encyclopedia reference citing Deerr, Dunn and Sheridan; the 450,000 indentured-labour figure for 1838 to 1917 is from the Museum of London Docklands; the labour comparison with tobacco and cotton is from the Wikipedia history of sugar, a secondary source, and is kept short. No share of the slave trade attributable to sugar is claimed. The image is a period drawing without graphic content.

More from this book

History · From the book Sugar: Plant, Crystal, Empire

The origin and history of sugar: from New Guinea cane to world commodity

Sugar began as a grass chewed for its juice.

Process · From the book Sugar: Plant, Crystal, Empire

How sugar is made from sugarcane: mill, boil, crystallise, refine

Sugar is made by squeezing juice from cane, cleaning it, boiling off the water and persuading sucrose to crystallise.

Raw material · From the book Sugar: Plant, Crystal, Empire

Beet sugar vs cane sugar: how Europe learned to make sugar at home

Sugar from beet and sugar from cane are the same molecule.

Product type · From the book Sugar: Plant, Crystal, Empire

Brown sugar vs white sugar: what molasses changes and what it does not

White sugar is sucrose with the molasses removed.