Cover of Sugar: Plant, Crystal, Empire, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book Sugar: Plant, Crystal, Empire
Part V: From plant to crystal. Read the full book free as a PDF.
Three heaps of granulated brown sugar in different shades photographed from above: dark muscovado at the top, dark brown on the left and golden brown on the right.
Brown sugar examples: muscovado (top), dark brown (left) and golden brown (right). Photo: Moe Rubenzahl, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What the difference is

The International Food Information Council says the main difference between table sugar and brown sugar is the presence of molasses, which gives brown sugar its colour, flavour and moisture. Both consist primarily of sucrose, a disaccharide made of equal parts fructose and glucose. Brown sugars come in forms such as coarse or soft depending on moisture, which can be adjusted by processing and by the amount of molasses.

Where the colour comes from

The World Sugar Research Organisation puts it directly: sugar is naturally white, and it is the naturally occurring molasses that gives brown sugar its colour. Refining removes the molasses in making white sugar. At the refinery, as described in how sugar is made from sugarcane, raw sugar is washed and melted, and the molasses film is spun off or washed away. The IFIC adds that the molasses used for brown sugar comes from sugar cane, not sugar beets.

Is brown sugar healthier?

The IFIC highlights say that brown sugar has about the same number of calories per teaspoon as white table sugar. There are trace amounts of nutrients from the molasses, but brown sugar is not considered healthier than other sugars. Choosing between them is about taste and baking, not health.

The range of brown sugars

The photograph shows a range from golden brown through dark brown to muscovado at the top, which is the least refined and darkest. The shade follows the molasses content. EPA's refinery description lists brown sugar as one of the common refined sugar products, next to granulated, powdered and liquid sugar and edible molasses.

What a buyer's specification says

The USDA's commercial item description for sugar (A-A-20135E) gives the clearest numbers. It sorts sugar into Type I, white refined, in granulated, superfine and powdered styles; Type II, brown, in light and dark styles; and Type III, other sugars such as turbinado and demerara, as the purchaser specifies. For the granulated and superfine styles (Styles A and B), white refined sugar must have at least 99.5 percent sucrose, no more than 0.04 percent ash and no more than 0.05 percent moisture, and be white, free-flowing crystals; powdered Style C has different limits. Brown sugar must have at least 86.0 percent sucrose, with maximum ash of 2.25 percent for light and 3.25 percent for dark, and maximum moisture of 4.5 percent. Light brown sugar has a soft texture, a uniform light to medium golden brown colour and a mild sweet molasses odour. Dark brown has a soft texture, a uniform brown colour, and a sweet molasses odour and flavour.

The origin of the crystallising craft is in the origin and history of sugar, and the beet side is in beet sugar versus cane sugar.

Quick answers

What is the difference between brown and white sugar?

Brown sugar contains molasses, which gives it colour, flavour and moisture. White sugar has had the molasses removed.

Is brown sugar healthier than white sugar?

The IFIC says it has about the same calories per teaspoon and is not considered healthier, although molasses adds trace nutrients.

What is muscovado?

The darkest of the brown sugars in the photograph, with the highest molasses content.

Does brown sugar come from sugar beets?

The molasses used for brown sugar comes from sugar cane, according to the IFIC.

Sources

Calorie, nutrition and molasses statements are from IFIC (a food-industry-funded information body) and WSRO (a sugar research body); they match each other. The USDA figures are a federal purchasing specification, not a legal definition of brown sugar for consumers.

More from this book

Process · From the book Sugar: Plant, Crystal, Empire

How sugar is made from sugarcane: mill, boil, crystallise, refine

Sugar is made by squeezing juice from cane, cleaning it, boiling off the water and persuading sucrose to crystallise.

History · From the book Sugar: Plant, Crystal, Empire

The origin and history of sugar: from New Guinea cane to world commodity

Sugar began as a grass chewed for its juice.

Raw material · From the book Sugar: Plant, Crystal, Empire

Beet sugar vs cane sugar: how Europe learned to make sugar at home

Sugar from beet and sugar from cane are the same molecule.

Social history · From the book Sugar: Plant, Crystal, Empire

Sugar and slavery: how a crop built the Atlantic trade in enslaved people

Sugar was not the only crop grown by enslaved people.