Cover of The Jet Engine: Fire in a Tube, and the End of Distance, a book by Ketineni RamaraoFrom the book The Jet Engine: Fire in a Tube, and the End of Distance
Chapter 47. Read the full book free as a PDF.

A lead measured in months

The de Havilland Comet 1 entered service with BOAC in 1952, years before an American jet airliner flew, and cruised higher and faster than any piston airliner. The cost was a pressurised cabin carried to altitudes that had not been tried in airline service.

The accidents

On 2 May 1953 a Comet broke up in a thunderstorm after leaving Calcutta, and the Indian inquiry blamed overstress from gusts or the pilot's reaction to them. The next two accidents were different. On 10 January 1954, BOAC Flight 781 (G-ALYP) was climbing through 27,000 feet near Elba when the radio went silent mid-sentence. All 35 on board died. After the fleet was checked and modified, flights resumed. On 8 April 1954 South African Airways Flight 201 (G-ALYY) broke up climbing through 35,000 feet near Naples, killing all 21. The Comet 1 fleet was grounded indefinitely in 1954, according to the FAA's Lessons Learned record.

A section of recovered Comet G-ALYP fuselage skin laid out on a frame in a museum, showing two hatches and rows of rivets.
Recovered fuselage skin from Comet G-ALYP, laid out on a frame for examination. Investigators reassembled wreckage from the sea to trace where the failure began. Photo: Krelnik, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

The water tank

Investigators recovered wreckage from the sea around Elba and rebuilt it. They also took a complete Comet fuselage, submerged it in a water tank and repeatedly pressurised and depressurised it to copy flight after flight. The NLR's account gives the numbers: the test aircraft had flown 1,231 pressurisation cycles in service. It sat in a water tank to limit damage if it failed, and after 1,825 test pressurisations the cabin failed during a proof cycle at 33 percent higher loading. Fatigue cracking had begun at the aft lower corner of the forward escape hatch. In the wreckage of G-ALYP, fatigue began at the corner of a rear window for the direction-finding aerial. A separate fatigue test of Comet G-ALYR, in the Court of Inquiry records, cracked the skin at the corners of nine windows and two escape hatches. The FAA concludes that the relatively squarish windows created stress concentrations far higher than anyone had expected.

The NLR adds one more detail. The cabin shell had no crack-stopper straps to carry the load across the cut-outs in the frames, so once a crack started in G-ALYP it grew unseen until the whole cabin failed. A crack that ran across one or two frame bays should have been large enough to find.

What the engineers had not known

The designers had not been careless in the usual sense. The cabin had passed strength tests well above its design load. What was not understood was that a structure can pass a strength test and still carry a crack that grows a little with every pressurisation, then runs. The investigation led to rounded windows, thicker skin, crack-stopping structure and a design philosophy of fail-safe and damage tolerance: assume cracks will appear and design for them to be found before they grow too long.

The redesigned Comet 4 flew from 1958 and the type served for decades. The book says Boeing and every maker after it built cabin test rigs of their own and designed to the Comet's lessons from the start; the NLR confirms that the accidents fundamentally changed the fatigue design principles for commercial transports.

What the story shows about jets

The Comet's Ghost engines were not the cause. The failure was in the airframe. But the crash belongs in the history of the jet engine because it is the clearest case of the new regime of speed and altitude punishing every unknown at full severity. The engine invented in the 1930s by Whittle and von Ohain opened the sky; the Comet showed what it cost to learn to live there.

Quick answers

Why did the de Havilland Comet crash?

Metal fatigue. Repeated pressurisation cycles created cracks at the corners of the squarish windows and hatches, which eventually ruptured the fuselage in flight.

How did investigators prove it was fatigue?

They recovered and rebuilt wreckage from the sea near Elba and tested a complete fuselage in a water tank, pressurising it repeatedly until it failed. Fatigue cracks formed at window and hatch corners.

What changed after the Comet accidents?

Aircraft got rounded windows, crack-stopping structure and a fail-safe, damage-tolerant design philosophy backed by inspection regimes.

Sources

Accident dates, flight numbers, deaths, the grounding and the squarish-window stress concentration are from the FAA Lessons Learned page. The water-tank test numbers, the crack origins and the missing crack-stopper straps are from the NLR report. The G-ALYR window and hatch cracks are from the Court of Inquiry report hosted by the FAA. The Comet 4 history follows Chapter 47 of the book.

More from this book

History · From the book The Jet Engine: Fire in a Tube, and the End of Distance

Who invented the jet engine? Whittle, von Ohain and the fire lit twice

Two men who did not know of each other's work, in two countries that would soon be at war, built a working turbojet at the same time.

Explainer · From the book The Jet Engine: Fire in a Tube, and the End of Distance

How a jet engine works: compressor, combustor, turbine, nozzle

A jet engine takes in slow air and throws out fast gas.

Engine design · From the book The Jet Engine: Fire in a Tube, and the End of Distance

Turbofan vs turbojet: why airliners moved the thrust to a fan

A turbojet pushes a little air very fast.

Materials · From the book The Jet Engine: Fire in a Tube, and the End of Distance

How jet engine turbine blades survive heat hotter than their melting point

In a modern jet engine the gas striking the first turbine blades is hotter than the metal would normally survive.